CORNELL

UNIVERSITY

LIBRARY

GIFT OF Nixon Griff is

Cornell University Library PR 6003.E47P23

Paris.

3 1924 013 585 843

The original of tliis book is in tine Cornell University Library.

There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text.

http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924013585843

PARIS

PARIS

BY

HILAIRE BELLOC

AUTHOR OF "dANTON"

LONDON

EDWARD ARNOLD

^xmA^tx to t^E Siittta ©«ce

I goo

TO

CHARLES SOMERS COCKS

PP- M

900328

f'f'

t3t.

PREFACE

There comes, I suppose, to every one who has felt keenly the modern impression of a place he loves, a desire to know its changing past, the nature and experience that it draws from the centuries, and the platform upon which there can be constructed some little of that future which he will never see. The more vivid be the contemporary effect of a city, the more urgently does the question of its origins and development press upon one. The sight of one's own time — even if it be stretched to a full lifetime — is but a glance taken rapidly upon a voyage, and leaves an enduring expectation and demand for further knowledge. In the effort to satisfy this a man will read this book and that, look up old prints and catch the chance phrases of memoirs; he will, for his own sake, clear out a rough sketch of the whole past of what he loves, and he will end by making a record that is as incomplete and fragmentary, as incongruous a mixture of the general theory of life and of particular trifles, as are the notes and letters we keep to remind us of absent friends.

This is the way my book was written, and this is the reason of its being written at all; so that the very many people who feel just the same happy curiosity about a living city may have a place in which another

viii PREFACE

person, to whom Paris is as dear and ignorance as tantalizing as to themselves, has roughly quarried a bare sufficiency of knowledge for his own satisfaction and theirs. This book belongs, then, to that kind of history (if it can be called history at all) which is as superficial and as personal as a traveller's drawing or as the notes of a man's diary, but which has its purpose because, like such sketches and memoranda, it serves to give just the necessary framework upon which the memory and imagination may build.

With this there will be evident the excuse that offers for the book's shortcomiags. They are many, but they are also very evidently dependent upon the character of work that I have described. Thus, every term I have used in architecture must show an ignorance of techni- calities : the pointed arch is, baldly, " the Gothic," and the style preceding it simply " the Eomanesque." Again, the few maps were drawn, or rather sketched, by the hand of an amateur, noting down only what would make his descriptions clearer and unable to pretend to the strict accuracy that should mark such work. Thus, there is very much omitted that a modern interest would claim; but here also it is the nature of the book that has interfered. If I have said nothing of the Miller's Bridge, it is because the Pont Notre Dame and the Pont au Change were better pegs on which to hang the story of the river. If the Pont St. Michel is hidden away in a footnote, it is because the Petit Pont, with its innumerable misfortunes, is so much more Parisian; if there is no mention of the new fortifications that kept out Henri IV., it is because the king himself seemed more necessary to the book than they. St. Eustache and

PREFACE ix

St. Etienne du Mont, St. Gervais, St. Jean, St. Sulpice, have had bare allusions where any careful student of Paris would demand full histories; but if these, and so many other separate sites — St. Martin, St. Laurent, the Place Vend6me, the Observatory, the Arsenal, the Culture Ste. Catherine, and a hundred others — have been hardly touched upon or left wholly aside, it is because, with so little space and with so much to say, the Louvre, the Hotel de Ville, Notre Dame — the framework of Paris — seemed more necessary, and absorbed the proper share of the less typical monuments.

There is another matter which the reader may find it harder to pardon, and which is yet, I think, equally a necessity. I have not pursued the description of the old city beyond 1789. And if it be asked what kind of " necessity " there was in this, the answer is that the old Paris, the past which we hardly know and which it concerns us to know, ends there. The hundred years that follow would indeed make a wonderful theme for any man to write on, but it would give him a task fundamentally different from the following of that long, continuous story which centered for so many centuries round the line of the Eues St. Jacques and St. Martin, and that was played upon the stage of the University and the Cathedral and the Louvre.

As for the authorities, it has not seemed necessary to quote them in such manner as to break the text of so slight an essay. Felibien has been the basis of this, as it must be of all similar books — very good reading, but a trifle clerical. ' Abbo has given me, as he gives all who care to read him, the vivid picture of the Norman siege ; Sauval, his seventeenth century and partial but accurate

X PREFACE

view. For the innumerable details of sites, and for its excellent imaginary reproductions of old Paris, I have, of course, used the great popular collection that Fournier edited; and for the rest a great deal of quotations, memories, and accidental reading have taken the place of what might have been a fuller research. On doubtful things I have simply taken of two or more conjectures that which seemed (for I know not what reason, unless it be a preference for the picturesque) the most probable. Did Genevieve die in 509 or 512 ? Did Childeric lay siege to Paris? Does there remain a Merovingian part in St. Germain des Pres ? Was not the Chatelet, in some part, a survival from the Tower of the Siege of 885 ? No one can be quite certain, and it matters little. But I beg the indulgence of those who take a view on any such matter different from that in my text, and I assure them that I have no confidence in my opinion.

One other thing remains. I have given half the book to the origins of Paris, and I have condensed, perhaps to excess, the later part. Why? Because in history we ought not to look down a perspective, but to travel along a road.

My thanks are due to Mr. Eccles and to Mr. Haynes, who have very kindly helped me with the proofs of this book, and in some measure (though I had the misfortune to speak to him for but a few moments on this subject) to the keeper of the Carnavalet, who, as I was writing my book, ended a long, honourable, and laborious life, still bent upon his work, and having earned the respect and almost the affection of every student of the city.

London, 1900.

CONTENTS

I. Introduction 1

II. The Plain op Paris 36

III. LUTETIA 57

IV. Paris m the Daek Ages 100

V. The Eaely Middle Ages 163

VI. The Later Middle Ages . . 225

Vn. The Eenaissanoe 301

VIII. The Kbbuilding 350

IX. The Eighteenth Century 410

Index 468

LIST OF MAPS AND PLANS

PAGE

Statue op Notee Dame de Paris Frontispiece

Sketch-map op Seine Valley . .... ... 38

Map of Eeliep op Plain of Paris ... . To face 42

Sketch-map of Original Group of Islands 48

Roman Paris . To face 98

Paris and Suburbs in Dark Ages .... .... 139

Mediaeval Paris To face 224

Rebuilding op Palais de Justice 434

PARIS

CHAPTEE I

INTRODUCTION

When a man looks eastward from the western heights that dominate the city, especially from that great hiU of Valerian (round which so many memories from Ste. Genevieve to the last war accumulate), a sight presents itself which shall be the modem starting-point of our study.

Let us suppose an autumn day, clear, with wind following rain, and with a grey sky of rapid clouds against which the picture may be set. In such a weather and from such a spot the whole of the vast town lies clearly before you, and the impression is one that you will not match nor approach in any of the views that have grown famous ; for what you see is unique in something that is neither the north nor the south ; something which contains little of scenic interest and nothing of dramatic grandeur ; men have forborne to describe it because when they have known Paris well enough to comprehend that horizon, why then, her people, her history, her life from within, have mastered every other interest and have occupied all their powers. Nevertheless, this sight, caught from the

2 PARIS

hill-top, shall be our first introduction to the city ; for I know of no other which so profoundly stirs the mind of one to whom the story and even the modern nature of the place is unknown.

There lies at your feet — its fortifications some two miles away — a great plain of houses. Its inequalities are lost in the superior height from which you gaze, save where in the north the isolated summit of Montmartre, with the great mass of its half-finished church, looks over the city and answers the hill of Valerian.

This plain of houses fiUs the eye and the mind, yet it is not so vast but that, dimly, on the clearest days the heights beyond it to the east can be just perceived, whiLe to the north the suburbs and the open country appear, and to the south the hills. Whiter than are the northern towns of Europe, yet standing under a northern sky, it strikes with the force of sharp contrast, and half explains in that one feature its Latin origin and destiny. It is veiled by no cloud of smoke, for industry, and more especially the industry of our day, has not been the motive of its growth. The fantastic and even grandiose effects which are the joy of London will never be discovered here. It does not fill by a kiud of gravitation this or that group of arteries ; it forms no line along the water-course, nor does it lose itseK in those vague contours which, in a merely mercantile city, the necessity of exchange frequently determines ; for Paris was not made by commerce, nor will any theory of material conditions and environment read you the riddle of its growth and form. ' It is not the mind of the on- looker that lends it unity, nor the emotions of travel that make it, for those who see it thus, one thing. Paris, as it lies before you beneath those old hiUs -that have watched

INTRODUCTION 3

it for two thousand years, has the effect and character of personal life. Not in a metaphor, nor for the sake of phrasing, but iu fact; as truly as in the case of Eome, though in a manner less familiar, a separate existence with a soul of its own appeals to you. Its voice is no reflection of your own mind ; on the contrary, it is a troubliiig thing, like an insistent demand spoken iu a foreign tongue. Its corporate life is not an abstraction drawn from books or from words one may have heard. There, visibly before you, is the compound of the modem and the middle ages, whose unity conviaces merely by beiug seen.

And, above all, this thing upon which you are looking is alive. It needs no recollection of what has been taught in youth, nor any of those reveries which arise at the identification of things seen with names remembered. The antiq^uarian passion, in its best form pedantic and iu its worst maudlin, finds little room in the first aspect of Paris. Later, it takes its proper rank in all the mass of what we may learn, but the town, as you see it, recalls history only by speaking to you in a living voice. Its past is still alive, because the city itself is still iastinct with a vigorous growth, and you feel with regard to Paris what you would feel with regard to a young man full of adventures : not at all the quiet interest which lies in the recollections of age ; stiU less that happy memory of things dead which is a fortune for so many of the most famous cities of the world.

Whence proceeds this impression, and what is the secret of its origin ? Why, that ia all this immense extent an obvious unity of design appears; not in one quarter alone, but over the whole circumference stand the evidences of this creative spirit. It is not the rich, building

4 PARIS

for themselves in their own quarter, nor the officials, concentrating the common wealth upon their own build- ings ; it is Paris, creating and recreating her own adorn- ment, realizing her own dreams upon every side, insisting on her own vagaries, committing follies which are her own and not that of a section of her people, even here and there chiselling out something as durable as Europe.

Look at the great line before you and note these evidences of a mind at work. Here, on your right, monstrous, grotesque, and dramatic in the extreme, rises that great ladder of iron, the Eiffel, to its thousand feet ; it was meant to be merely engineering, and therefore christened at its birth by all the bad fairies, but it yet contrives (as though the spirit of the city had laughed at its own folly) to assume something of grace, and loses, in a very delicate grey, in a good curve, and in a film of fine lines, the grossness which its builders intended. It stands up, close to our western standpoint, foolishly. It is twice as high as this hUl of Valerian from which we are looking; its top is covered often in hurrying clouds, and it seems to be saying perpetually: "I am the end of the nineteenth century ; I am glad they built me of iron; let me rust." It is far on the outskirts of the town, where aU the rest of the things that Paris has made can look at it and laugh contentedly. It is like a passing fool in a crowd of the University, a buffoon in the hall; for of aU the things that Paris has made, it alone has neither wits nor soul.

But just behind it and somewhat to the left the dome you see gilded is the InvaKdes, the last and, perhaps, the best relic of seventeenth-century taste, and with that you touch ground and have to do with Paris again ; for just

INTRODUCTION 5

beneath it is Napoleon, and in the short roof to the left of it, in the chapel, the flags of all the nations. Behind that, again, almost the last thing the eighteenth century left us, is the other dome of the Pantheon. The great space in ideas that lies between it and the Invalides is the space between Mansard and Soufflot; its dome is in a false proportion ; a great hulking colonnade deforms its middle ; its sides and its decorations are cold and bare. The gulf between these two, compared, is the gulf between Louis XIV. and the last years of decay that made necessary the Eevolution. It stands, grey, ugly, and without mean- ing, the relic of a grey and ugly time. But you note that it caps a little eminence, or what seems, from our height and distance, to be a little eminence. That hUl is the hill of Ste. Genevieve, the "Mons Lucotitius." On its sides and summit the University grew, and at its base the Revolution was born in the club of the Cordeliers.

It will repay one well to look, on this clear day, and to strain the eyes in watching that hummock — a grey and confused mass of houses, with the ugly dome I spoke of on its summit. A lump, a little higher than the rest, halfway up the hill, is the Sorbonne; upon the slopes towards us two unequal square towers mark St. Sulpice — a heap of stones. Yet all this confusion of unlovely things, which the distance turns into a blotch wherein the Pantheon alone can be distinguished, is a very noteworthy square mUe of ground ; for at its foot Julian the Apostate held his little pagan circle; at its summit are the relics of Ste. Genevieve. Here Abelard awoke the "great curiosity " from its long sleep, and here St. Bernard answered him in the name of all the mystics. Here Dante studied, here Innocent III. was formed, and here

6 PARIS

Calvin the Picard preached his Batavian theory. Here is the unique arena where Catholicism and the Eationalists meet, and where a great struggle is never completed. Here, as in symbol of that wrestling, the cross is per- petually rising above and falling from the Pantheon — now torn down, now reinstated. Beneath that ugly dome lie Voltaire and Eousseau ; in one of the gloomy buildings on that hill Eobespierre was taught the .stoicism of the ancients and sat on the bench with Desmoulins; at its flank, in the Cordeliers, Danton forged out the scheme of the EepubUc; it was thence that the fire spread in '92 which overthrew the old regime; here, again, the students met and laughed and plotted against the latest despotism. It was from the steps of that unlovely Pantheon, with "To the great men of France" carved above him, that Gambetta declared the third Eepublic. It was the 4th of September, 1870, and it rained.

There is, however, ia the view before you another spot, almost touching the hill which we have been noting, and of yet more importance in the story of the city, though it may not be so in the story of the world — I mean the Island of the Cite.

From this distance we cannot see the gleam of the water on either side of it ; moreover, the houses hide the river and the bridges. Nevertheless, knowing what lies there, we can make out the group of buildings which is the historic centre of Paris, and from which the town has radiated outwards during the last fourteen centuries.

We are five miles away, and catch only its most evident marks. We see the square mass of the Palais, whence, uniaterruptedly, for eighteen hundred years the government has held its courts and its share in the

INTRODUCTION 7

administration of the town. Perhaps, if it is very clear, the conical roofs of the twin towers of the Concier- gerie can be made out; and, certainly, to the right of them we see the high-pitched roof and the thin spire of the Sainte Chapelle, which St. Louis built to cover the Holy Lance and the Crown of Thorns. But the most striking featui-e of the Island and the true middle of the whole of Paris will be clear always even at this distance — I mean the Cathedral of Notre Dame.

The distance and the larger aspect of nearer things make exiguous the far towers as they stand above the houses. You look, apparently, at a little thing, but even from here it has about it the reverence of the Middle Ages. In that distance all is subdued ; but these towers, which are grey to a man at their very feet, seem to possess to a watcher from Valerian the quality of a thin horizon cloud.

I know not how to describe this model of the Middle Ages — built into the modern town, standing (from which- ever way you look) in its very centre, so small, so distant, and yet so majestic. Amiens and Eheims, Strasburg, Chartres, and Eouen — all the great houses of the Gothic, as they pass before the mind, have something at once less pathetic and less dignified. They are no larger than Notre Dame ; they have not — even Eheims has not — her force of repose, of height, and of design. But they stand in provincial cities. The modem world affects, without transforming, their surroundings. Amiens stands head and shoulders above the town ; Eheims, as you see it coming in from camp, looks like a great sphinx brooding over the Champagne and always gazing out to the west and the hills of the Tourdenoise ; Strasburg is almost

8 PARIS

theatrical in its assertion; Chartres is the largest thing in a rural place, and is the natural mother of the Beauce, the patroness and protectress of endless fields of corn ; and even the Cathedral of Eouen, though it stands in the confusion of machiaery and in the centre of modern things, is so placed that, come from whichever way you will, it is the mistress of the town.

But Notre Dame is always one of many things and not the greatest. It was built for a little Gothic capital, and a huge metropolis has outgrown her. The town was once, so to speak, the fringe of her garment ; now she is but the centre of a circle miles around. There are but three spots in Paris from which the old church alone can fill the eye as do the churches of the provincial towns ; I mean from the Quai de la Tournelle, from the Parvis, and from the Place de Grfeve. And yet it gradually becomes more to the spirit of those who see it than do any of those other churches, for the very anomaly of its position leads to close observance, and it touches the mind at last like a woman who has been continually silent in a strange company. To a man who loves and knows the city, there soon comes a desire to communicate con- stantly with the memories of the Cathedral. And this desire, if he is wise, grows into a habit of coming close against the towers at evening, or of waiting under the great height of the nave for the voices of the Middle Ages.

Notre Dame thus lost in distance, central and remote, is Uke a lady grown old in a great house, about whose age new phrases and strange habits have arisen, who is surrounded with the youth of her own lineage, and yet is content to hear and understand without replying to their speech. She is silent in the midst of energy, and

INTRODUCTION 9

forgotten in the many activities of the household, yet she is the centre of the estate.

There stands, then, in the midst of our view, this little group of the Island of the Cit6, the old Eoman town with which so much of this history wUl deal. As the eye turns to the left, that is to the northern half of the town, it is passing over the place of its great expansion. It is here that Paris has worked and has grown, while Paris of the centre governed and Paris of the south thought and studied. It is in this half of the city that we shall note her greatest theatres, her most famous modern streets, her houses of rich men, her palaces, even her industries.

But this northern half has little to distinguish it in a general panorama ; here and there a spire, or tower, or a column, but as a rule only a mass of high houses, in which the distant Louvre alone seems to possess special prominence, and in which the Palais Eoyal, the Madeleine, the Bourse are so many roofs only, conspicuous in nothing but their surface. The old world makes but little effect from the distance at which we stand, and indeed is less apparent in the northern half of the city even to a spectator who is placed within its streets. Close against the Island you may perhaps catch the fine square tower of St. Jacques, the last of the Gothic ; but with that exception the view of the left side is modern. If we may connect it with any one period or man rather than another, it is the later Eevoliition and Napoleon that it recalls. Between us and the heart of the city is the ridge of Passy ; less than a mile from the fortifications and on the summit of this ridge, the great Triumphal Arch, full of his battles and his generals' names.

You may see beyond it, towards the more central parts

lo PARIS

of the town, a line here and there of those straight streets so many of which he planned, and nearly all of which are due to his influence upon Paris. Thus, opening straight before you, but miles away, running past the Louvre and on to the HStel de VUle, is that Eue de Eivoli, made long after his reign, and yet so characteristically his. Ob- literating, as did his own career, the memories of the Eevolution ; running over the spot where the riding-school stood, and where Mirabeau helped to found a new world ; draining the Eue St. Honore (that Eepublican gulf) of half its traffic, it strikes the note of the new Paris which the nineteenth century has designed.

Just off the line of this street you may catch the bronze column, the Vendome, which again perpetuates Napoleon ; it stands well above the houses, and rivals the other column which the distance almost hides, and which overlooks the site of the Bastille.

But when we have noted these few points, have tried to make out the new Hotel de Ville (as distant and less clear than Notre Dame), and have marked the great mass of the Opera roof, the general aspect of the northern bank is told. There is nothing on which the eye rests as a central point. Only in itself, and without the aid of monuments, the great expanse of wealth and of energy fringing off into the industries of the northern and western roads shows us at once the modern Paris that works and enjoys.

One last feature remains to be spoken of while we are still looking upon this view, and before we go down into the city to notice the closer aspect of its streets and buildings. I mean the hill of Montmartre. It lies on the extreme left of the plain, that is in the northernmost

INTRO D UCTION 1 1

part of the city, just within the fortifications, and rises, isolated and curiously steep, above the whole level of the northern quarter. No city has so admirable a place of vantage, and in no other is the position so unspoiled as here. For centuries, from the time when it was far out- side the mediaeval walls, Montmartre has been the habita- tion of bohemians and chance poor men. Lucidly it has remained undisturbed to this day. And if you climb it, you look right down upon the town from the best and most congenial of surroundings. Nothing there reminds you of a municipality forcing you to acknowledge the site and the view. There is not a park or statue, not even a square. A ramshackle cafe with dirty plaster statues, a half-finished church, a panorama of the True Jerusalem (the same all falling to pieces with old age and neglect), a number of little houses and second-rate villas, a few dusty studios ; this is the furniture of the platform beneath which aU Paris lies rolled out.

Long may it remain so untouched, in spite of many pilgrimages. For the hill is now truly Parisian. The tourist does not hear of it, even the systematic traveller avoids it. But it is dear to the student, and to that type in which Paris is so prolific; I mean the careless and disreputable young men who grow up to be bourgeois and pillars of society. For them the slopes of the hill are almost sacred. Half the minor verse of Paris has been written here, and that other hiU of the Latin quarter has arranged, as it were, for its play-ground in this for- saken and neglected place. Paris inspires you weU as you look down upon it from such surroundings, and for one who understands the race there is a peculiar pleasure in noting that officialism, which is one aspect of the

13 PARIS

national character, has spared Montmartre to the careless- ness and excess which is its paradoxical second half. N"ot so long ago a crazy windmill marked the summit. It has disappeared, but it is characteristic of the hill that it should have lingered to so late a date. Not another square yard of Paris, perhaps, has been so left to chance as this admirable opportunity for the interference of official effect. But even as I write this, the great new church threatens to make it clean and orderly and known.

Such, imperfectly described, is Paris when you see it first from the highest of the western hills. But my in- sistence upon this or that particular point must not mis- represent to my reader the general effect. These domes, arches, towers, spires — even the hills, are but incidents in the vast plain of houses with which my summary began, and which is the note of the whole scene. What is this plain, seen from within ? What is the character of its life, its architecture, its monuments? Above all, what surmise gradually rises in us as we pass through its streets and try to discover the historic foundations upon which all this modern society rests ?

This is what you will notice as you pass through the thoroughfares of Paris — an old and a new thing mingling. Two kinds of streets, and, to match them, two kinds of public buildings; and yet neither clearly defined, but merging into one another in a fashion which, as will be seen later, gives the characteristic of continuity to the modern town.

As an example of the first, take the Eue St. Honore ; as an example of the second, its immediate neighbour, the

INTRODUCTION 13

Boulevard de la Madeleine. The Eue St. Honore is narrow, paved with square stones, sounding like a gorge on the sea-coast. Its houses are high, and with hardly a pretence of decoration. Their stone or plastered walls run grey and have black streaks with age. Commonly an old iron balcony wUl run along one or more of the upper stories. They are covered with green-grey Mansard roofs, high in proportion to the buildings. Prom these look the small windows of attics, where, in the time these houses were bmlt, the apprentices and servants of the bourgeois householders were lodged. The ground floor, as everywhere in Paris, is a line of shops. The street is not only narrow and high, but sombre in effect. Here and there (but rarely) an open court, looking almost like a well, lets in more light. The street is not straight, but follows the curves of the old mediaeval artery upon which it was built. You would look in vain for the Gothic in such streets as these. Even the Eenaissance has hardly remained. Their churches and their public buildings date from much the same time as the houses. They are uniformly of the seventeenth or early eighteenth century. It was in such surroundings that the Grand Siecle moved, and in such Hotels lived the dramatists and the orators of the Augustan age of Prench literature. These streets, all of much the same type, are the old Paris. They are least disturbed, perhaps, in the Latia quarter. They are, of course, not to be found in all that outer ring of the city which has been the creation of our own time, and in fine they still make up a good proportion of the circle within the boulevards, which is the heart of Paris. It is in them that you will note the famous sites of the last two hundred years almost unchanged, and it is under their

14 PARIS

influence that the student can at last reproduce the scenes and the spirit of the Eevolution.

Whole sections of the town— the He St. Louis, for example — show no architecture but this, and the high, sad houses, the narrow, sombre streets, the age-marked grey walls are stUl what most remains in the mind of one who loves and has known Paris.

Through these old quarters, cutting them up, as it were, into isolated sections, the modern streets run like a gigantic web of straight lines. The foundation of the system is the ring of internal boulevards. Here and there, within their limits, great supplementary avenues cut through the heart of the city, and finally the inner and the outer boulevards are similarly connected with a series of broad streets lined with trees. Thus the new Paris holds the old, as a frame-work of timbers may hold an old wall, or as the veins of a leaf hold its substance.

And what is to be said of these new streets, and of the new quarters about the interior of the city ? It is the fashion to belittle their effect, and more especiaily do foreigners, whose foreign pleasures are catered for in the newest of the new streets, compare unfavourably this modern Paris with the old. They are heard to regret the rookeries of the Boucherie. They would not have the tower of St. Jacques stand in a public square, and some, I dare say, have found hard words even for the great space in front of Notre Dame, and for its statue of Charlemagne.

This attitude with regard to the new Paris seems to me a false one. Certainly its architecture suffers from uniformity. Light rather than mystery, comfort rather than beauty, has been the object of its design. They are

INTRODUCTION ij

to be regretted, but they are the characters of our gene- ration. And Paris, being a living and a young city, not a thing for a museum, nor certainly a place for fads and make-believes, it is well that our century should confess itself even in the Haussmanized streets, in the wide, shaded avenues of three, or even five, carriage roads side by side, and in the perpetual repetition of one type of modern house.

Moreover, Paris is here very true to the character she has maintained in each one of her rebuildings. She shows the whole spirit of the time. If she gives us, in a certain monotony and scientific precision and an over-cleanliness, the faults of the new spirit, she certainly has all its virtues. Her taste is excellent. These open spaces and broad streets make vistas or approaches of an admirable balance for the monuments. You will see them lead either to the best that is left of her past, or to the more congruous designs of her modern public buildings, and the effect, never sinking to the secondary, often rises to the magnificent. Take (for example) the present treatment of the Tuileries. The Commune burnt that old palace, leaving the three sides of the Louvre surrounding a gaping space. It has been harmonized with the Tuileries gardens by planting, and the whole great sweep down from the Arc de I'Etoile, though the TuUeries gardens to the court of the Louvre is, as it were, an approach to the palace. The grandeur of that scene has the demerit of being obvious, but it has also the singular value of obtruding nothing that can offend or distract the eye.

Even the Avenue de I'Opera, with the huge building at the end of it, will bear praise. If it lacks meaning, yet it does not lack greatness, and the Opera itself has

1 6 PARIS

something in it of the fantastic which avoids the grotesque. It is a " Palais du Diable," and it is not a little to say for a modem building that it holds the statuary well and harmoniously, especially when there are such groups in that statuary as " La Danse."

Moreover, if you will notice, Paris does not so announce her failures ; no great avenue leads up to and frames, for instance, the Trocadero.

As to the silly reasoning that any rebuilding was an error, it is fit only for a club of antiquarians. Paris has rebuilt herself three separate times, and had she not done so we should have none of those architectural glories which are her pride to-day. The Revolution was not the first profound change of ideas that the city experienced. The great awakening that made the University turned Paris into a Gothic city almost in a generation. The " Grand Siecle " swept away that Gothic city, and re- placed it by the tall houses that yet mark all her older quarters. In this last expansion Paris is but following a well-known road of hers, and the people who will come long after us will find it a good thing that she did so.

This also is to be noted : that if Paris is somewhat negligent of what is curious, yet she is careful of what is monumental. As we shall see in this book, the twelfth and even the sixth centuries — the fourth also in one spot — come against one in the midst of a modern street. Much that has been destroyed was not destroyed by the icono- clasm of the nineteenth, but by the sheer lack of taste of the eighteenth century — a time that could add the horrible false-Eenaissance portico to the exquisite Cathedral of Metz and that was capable of the Pantheon, pulled down without mercy. We suffer from it yet.

INTRODUCTION n

There is one feature which is perhaps not over-obvious in the buildings of Paris, and which it is well to point out in this connection, especially as it is the modern parallel of a spirit which we shall find in all the history of the town. I mean a remarkable historical continuity.

Paris to the stranger is new. Or at least where it evidently dates from the last, or even from the seventeenth century, it yet seems poor in those groups of the Middle Ages which are the characteristic of so many European towns, and one would say at first sight that it was entirely lacking in many relics of still earlier times. This im- pression is erroneous, not only as to the actual buildings of the city, but especially as to its history and spirit. But it is not without an ample excuse. There is nothing in Paris so old but that its surroundings give it a false aspect of modernity, nor is there any monument so venerable but that some part of it (often some part connected with the identity of the main building) dates from our own time.

The reason for this is twofold. Pirst, Paris has never been checked in its development. You find no relics, because it has never felt old age, and that species of forgetfulness which is necessary to the preservation of old things untouched has never fallen upon her. For, if you will consider, it is never the period j%st past which we revere and with which we forbear to meddle ; it is always something separated by a century at least from our own time. It needs, therefore, for the growth of ruins, and even for the preservation of old things absolutely un- changed, a certain period of indifference, in which they are neither repaired nor pulled down, but merely neglected. Thus we owe Eoman ruins to the Dark Ages, much of the

c

i8 PARIS

English Gothic to the indifference of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Such periods of indifference Paris has never experienced. Each age in her history, at least for the last six hundred years, has been " modern," has thought itself excellent, has designed in its own fashion. And on this account the conductor of Cook's tourists can find in the whole place but little matter for that phrase so dear to his flock : " It might have stepped out of the Middle Ages."

Secondly, her buildings are at the present moment, and have been from the time of the Eevolution, kept to a use, repaired, and made to enter into the present Mfe of the city. The modern era in Paris has had no sympathy with that point of view so common in Europe, which would have a church or a palace suffer no sacrilegious hand, but remain a kind of sacred toy, until it positively falls with old age, and has to be rebuilt entirely. The misfortune (for example) which gives us in Oxford the monstrosity of Balliol new buildings in the place of the exc[uisite four- teenth-century architecture, of which one comer yet remains to shame us ; such accidents to the monuments of the past Paris has carefully avoided. She was taught the necessity of this by the eighteenth-century conservatism, and if she is too continually repairing and replacing, it is a reaction from a time when the stones of the capital, like the institutions of the State, had been permitted to rot in decay.

There are one or two points of view in Paris from which this character is especially notable. We shall see it best, of course, where the oldest monuments naturally remain — I mean in the oldest quarter of the city. Stand on the northern quay that faces the Conciergerie and the

INTRODUCTION 19

Palais de Justice, and look at their walls as they rise above the opposite bank of the stream. What part of this is old and what new ? Unacquainted with the nature of the city, it would be impossible to reply. That Gothic arch- way might have been pierced in our century ; the clock- tower, with its fresh paint and the carefully repaired mouldings on its corners, might be fifty years old. Those twin towers of the Conciergerie might be of any age, for all the signs they give of it. Part of that building was destroyed in the Commune, and has been rebuilt. Which part ? There is nothing to tell. It is only when we know that it is against the whole genius of the people to imitate the styles of a dead age — when we are told (for example) that such things as " the Gothic Eevival," under which we groan in England to-day, and which is the curse of Oxford and Hampstead, has not touched Paris — it is only when we appreciate that the French either create or restore, but never copy, that we can see how great a work has been done on this one building.

The wall and the towers before you are not a curiosity or a show ; decay has not been permitted to touch them ; they are in actual service to-day in the working of the law-courts. Yet that corner clock-tower was the delight of Philippe le Bel. It was PliiLippe the Conqueror who built those two towers, with their conical roofs, and from one of their windows he would sit looking at the Seine flowing by, as his biographer describes him ; through that pointed archway St. Louis went daily to hear the pleas in the Palace gardens ; from such and such a window the last defence of Danton was caught by the mob that stretched along the quay and over the Pont Neuf.

Or, again, take a contrasting case — one where a

20 PARIS

spectator would believe all to be old, and yet where the moderns have restored and strengthened. As you stand on the quays that flank the Latin quarter and look north- ward to the Island and the whole southern side of Notre Dame, it is not only the thirteenth century at which you gaze; at point upon point Viollet le Due rebuilt and refaced many of the stones — some, even, of the carvings are his work ; yet you could never distinguish in it all what aid the present time had given to the work of St. Louis.

As for the Sainte Chapelle, it is at this day so exactly what it was when St. Louis first heard Mass in it — and that has been done at the expense of so much blue and gold, just such colour as he used — that the traveller wiU turn from it under the impression that he is suffering at the hands of the third Eepublic. It is only when you note that the stained glass is the gaudiest thing in the place that you begin to feel that here alone, perhaps, in Europe, the men who designed the early Gothic would feel at home.

And if this continuity in her buildings is so striking a mark of modem Paris, and goes so far to explain its newness, you will find something yet more remarkable in the preservation of its sites. To take but three: the place of the administration, of the central worship, and of the markets, are as old as the Eoman occupation. The Louvre has grown steadily from similar use to similar use through nearly a thousand years ; the Hotel de Ville through more than seven hundred. And a man may go over the Petit Pont from the southern bank, cross the Island, and come over to the northern side by the Pont Notre Dame, and be following step by step the road that

INTRODUCTION 21

SO spanned the two branches of the stream centuries and centuries ago — the road of Eoman times, and of years earlier yet — back in the beginning, when the Cite was a group of round Gaulish huts, and when two rough wooden bridges led the traveller across the Seine on his way to the sea-coast.

And this continuity in buildings and in places is matched by one spirit running all through the action of Paris for fifteen hundred years. This is the fixed interest of her history, and it is this which so many men have felt who, in studios, or up on the hill of the Uni- versity, though they had learned nothing of the past of the city, yet feel about them a secular experience and a troubling message difficult to understand — that seems to sum up in a confused sound the long changes of Christendom and of the West.

Well, what is the peculiar spirit, the historical mean- ing, of the town whose outer aspect I have hitherto been describing? No history can have value — it would perhaps be truer to say that no history can exist — unless while it describes it also explains. Here we shall have to deal with a city many of whose actions have been unique, much of whose life has been dismissed in phrases of wonder, of fear, or even of impotent anger. If this is all that a book can do for Paris, it had better not have been written. To stand aghast at her excesses, to lift up the hands at her audacity, or to lose control over one's pen in expressing abhorrence for her success, is to do what any scholar might be proud to accomplish, but it would be to fail as an historian. Why has Paris so acted? The answer to that question, and a sufiScient

22 PARIS

answer, alone can give such a story value. What is her nature ? What is, if we may use a term properly applicable only to human beings, her mind ?

You wiU not perceive the drift towards the true reply by following any of those laborious methods which stultify so much of modern analysis. You will not interpret Paris by any examination of her physical environment, nor comprehend her by one of those cheap racial generalizations that are the bane of popular study. In all the great truths spoken by Michelet, one is perhaps pre-eminent, because it seems to include all the others. He says : " La France a fait la France ; " and if this be true (as it is) of the nation, it is more especially true of the town. There is within the lives of individuals — as we know by experience — a something formative that helps to build up the whole man and that has a share in the result quite as large as the grosser part for which science can account. So it is with states, and so, sometimes, with cities. A destiny runs through their development which is allied in nature to the human soul, and which material circumstances may bound or may modify, but which certainly they cannot originate.

In the first place, Paris is, and has known itself to be, the City-State of modem Europe. What is the im- portance of that character ? Why, that certain habits of thought, certain results in politics which we can observe in the history of the City-State of antiquity, are to be noted repeating themselves in the actions and in the opinions of Paris. It is a phenomenon strange to the industrial nations of to-day, yet one with which society will always have to deal, perhaps at bottom the most durable thing of aU — that men will associate and act by

INTRODUCTION 23

neighbom-hood rather than by political definitions. And this influence of neighbourhood, which (with the single important exception of tribal society) is the greatest factor in social history, has formed the village community and the walled _town, whose contrast and whose co-existence are almost the whole history of Europe. When great Empires arise, a fictitious veil is thrown over these radical things. Men are attached to a wide and general patriotism covering hundreds of leagues, and even in the last stages of decay, and just before the final cataclysm, rhetoricians love to talk of a federation of all peoples, and merchants ardently describe the advent of a universal peace. But even in such exceptional periods in the history of man- kind, the village community and its parallel, the city, are the real facts in political life; and when, in the inevitable fall and the subsequent reconstruction of society, the fictions are destroyed and the phrases lose themselves in realities, these fundamental and original units re-emerge rugged and strong.

Upon the recognition of such units the healthy life of the Middle Ages reposed; in the satisfactory and human conditions of such societies the arts and the enthusiasms of Greece took life. It was in the autono- mous cities of Italy that our civilization reappeared, and the aristocratic conceptions upon which the social order of Europe is still founded sprang from the isolation and local politics of the manor.

In a time when the facility of communication has been so greatly augmented, and when therefore the larger units of political society should be supreme, Paris still proves to the modern world how enduring the primal instincts of our political nature are and must be.

24 PARIS

The unit that can practically see, understand, and act at once and together ; the " city that hears the voice of one herald," is living there in the midst of modem Europe. By a paradox which is but one of many in French politics, the centre which first gave out to other societies the creed of the large self-governing state, the power whence radiated the enthusiasm even for a federal humanity, " the capital of the Eepublic of mankind " from which poor Clootz, the amiable but mad German Baron, dated his correspondence — this very town is itself an example of an intense local patriotism, peculiar, narrow, and exclusive.

Paris acts together ; its citizens think of it perpetually as of a kind of native country, and it has established for itself a definition which makes it the brain of that great sluggish body, the peasantry of France. In that definition the bulk of the nation has for centuries acquiesced, and the birthplace of government by majority is also the spot where distinction of political quality and the right of the head to rule all the members is most imperiously asserted.

It is from this standpoint that so much of her history takes on perspective. By recognizing this feature the chaos of a hundred revolts assumes historical order. You wiU perceive from it the Parisian mob, with all the faults of a mob, yet organizing, creating, and succeeding ; you will learn why an apparently causeless outburst of anger has been fruitful, and why so much violence and so much disturbance should have aided rather than retarded the development of France.

It is as the City-State (and the metropolis at that) that Paris has been the self-appointed guardian of the French idea. Throughout the Middle Ages you will see

INTRODUCTION 2;

her anxious with a kind of prevision to safeguard the unity of the nation. For this she watches the diplomacy of the Capetians and fights upon their side, for this she ceaselessly stands watch with the king over feudalism, and doubles his strength in every blow that is dealt against the nobles. It is this feature that explains her attitude as the ally of Philip the Conqueror, her leaning later on the Burgundian house, her hatred of the southerner in the person of the Armagnac.

You will find it, without interruption, guiding her conduct in the history which links the Middle Ages to our own time. She is the faithful servant of Louis XI. ; she is the bitter fanatic for religious unity in the religious wars. Thus you see her withstanding Henry IV. to the last point of starvation, and thus a population, careless of religion, yet forces a religious formula upon the Hugue- not leader ; and when the first Bourbon accepted the Mass with a jest, it was Paris which had exacted, even from a conqueror, the pledge of keeping the nation one.

In the Eevolution all this character appears in especial relief. She claims to think for and to govern France; she asserts the right by her energy and initiative to defend the whole people and their new institutions from the in- vader, and she ratifies that assertion by success. With this leading thought she first captures, then imprisons, and finally overthrows the king ; lays (on the 2nd of June) violent hands upon the parliament, directs the terror, and then, when her system is no longer needed, permits in Thermidor the overthrow of her own spokesman.

If the condition of the city is considered, the causes of this strong local unity will become apparent. Paris is a microcosm. She contains all the parts proper to a

26 PARIS

little nation, and by the reaction of her own attitude this complete character is intensified; for, since she is the head of a highly organized State, all is to be found there. Here are at once the national and the urban government ; the schools for every branch of technical training. Here is the centre of the arts — not by a kind of accident such as will make the London artists live in Fitz-Johns Avenue, nor by the natural attraction of the great schools of the past, nor through peculiar collections such as cause the congeries at Munich, at Venice, or at Florence, or at Eome, but by a deliberate purpose : by the placing within the walls of the city of all the best teaching that the con- centrated effort of the nation can secure.

Within her walls are all the opposing factors of a vigorous life. She is not wholly student nor wholly in- dustrial nor wholly mercantile, but something of all three. Even the noble is present to add his little different note to the harmonious discord of competing interests; and, alone of the great capitals of the world, she is the seat of the old University of the nation. Here, running wild through a whole quarter of the city, is that vigorous youth, undiscoverable in London or in Berlin ; I mean the follies, the loves, and the generous ideals of the students. They keep it fresh with a laughter that is lacking in the centres of the modern world, and they supply it with a frank criticism bordering on iatellectual revolt, which the self- satisfaction of less fortunate capitals, mere seaports, or military centres, fatally ignores. The young men, from their high attic windows on the Hill, interpret her horizons ; and, as they grow to fill the places of the old, such a youth helps them to keep the city worthy of the impressions with which she delighted their twentieth year.

INTRODUCTION 27

And Paris has also the last necessary quality for the formation of a City-State. I mean that her stories are so many memories of action which she has undertaken unaided, and that her view of the past is one in which she continually stands alone. It is a record of great sieges, in which no outer help availed her, and in which she fell throiigh isolation or succeeded by her own powers. More than one of her monuments is a record of action that she undertook before the nation which depends upon her was willing to move; and she records herself, from the Column of July to the Arsenal of the InvaMes, the successful leader ta movements that the general people applauded but could not design.

Her history has finally produced in her what was in the Middle Ages but a promise or perhaps a thing in germ — the sentiment and the expression of individuality. She has known herself. The story of her growth from the origins of her political position under the early Capetians, through the episode of Etienne Marcel to the definite action of the seventeenth century and finally of the Eevolution, is the story of a personality growing from mere sensation to self-recognition, and from embryonic confusion to functions determinate and understood. It is a transition from instinct to reason ; and at its close you have, as was expressed at the opening of this chapter, a true and living unit, not in metaphor but in fact, with a memory, a will, a voice, and an expression of its own.

Such is the first great mark of Paris, and with that clue alone in one's hand the maze is almost solved.

But, if Paris has these characteristics of continuity and of being the City-State, she has also a third, which,

28 PARIS

while it is less noticeable to her own citizens, is yet more interesting to the foreigner than the other two. She is the typical city of the western civilization — I mean, her history at any moment is always a peculiarly vivid reflec- tion of the spirit which runs through western Europe at the time. She leads and originates where France is con- cerned. To say that she does so for Europe (which is a commonplace with her historians) is not strictly true ; it is more accui-ate to say that she mirrors. It cannot be denied that her action at such and such a crisis has differed from the general action of the European cities ; nor can it be forgotten that her course has more than once pro- duced a sense of intolerable contrast in the minds of her neighbours. Paris has not been typical in the sense of being the average. That character would have produced a history devoid of features, whereas all the world knows that the history of Paris is a series of strong pictures most often overdrawn. If she has been the typical city of the west, it is rather in this sense, that on her have been focussed the various rays of European energy ; that she has been the stage upon which the contemporary emotions of Europe have been given personce through whose lips they could find expression ; that she has time and time again been the laboratory wherein the problems that perplexed our civilization have always been analyzed and sometimes solved.

It may be urged that every city partakes of this character, and that the civilization which has grown up upon the ruins of Eome is so much of a unity that its principal cities have always reflected the spirit of their time. This is true. But Paris has reflected that spirit with a peculiar fidelity. While she has, of course, been

INTRODUCTION 29

filled with her own strong bias of race and of local character, yet her treatment of this or that time has been remarkable for proportion ; you feel, in reading of her past action, that not the north or the south, nor this people or that, but all Europe is (so to speak) being " played " before your eyes. The actors are French and, commonly, Parisian ; the language they speak is strange and the action local, yet the subject-matter is something which concerns the whole of our world, and the place given to each part of the movement is that which, on looking over the surrounding nations, we should assign to it were we charged with drawing up an accurate balance of the time.

Before pointing out the historical examples which show how constantly Paris has been destined to fill this inter- national part, it is well to appreciate the causes of such a position. First among these comes the feature which has been discussed above. The fact that she contains within her walls all the parts of a State fits her for the character of representative, and makes her action more complete than is the case with another European city. The interests of exchange and of commerce, of finance (which in this age may almost be called a separate thing); the struggle between the proletariat and capital; the unsatisfied quarrel between dogmatic authority and the inductive method ; militarism, and the reaction it creates ; even the direction which literature and discussion may give to these energies — all these are found within the city, and the general result is a picture of Europe. But this quality of hers is not the only cause of her typical character. Geographical position explains not a little of its origin. She is of Latin origin and of Latin tradition ; her law and much of her social custom is an inheritance from Piome,

30 PARIS

yet the basis of the race is not Latin, and among those in the studios who almost reproduce the Greek, there is hardly a southern face to be found. Her lawyers and orators will model themselves upon Latin phrases, but you would not match their expression among the Eoman busts ; and it has been truly said that the Italian profile was more often met with in England than in northern France. Even the insular civilization of England, which has had so great an effect upon the politics, if not the society, of the world, is to be found strongly represented in this medley. For England looks south (or, at least, the England which possessed so great a moral influence did so), and Paris is geographically the centre of those northern provinces, and socially of that governing middle class upon whom the British influence has been strong. Though this part of her thought is of less importance than some others, yet it is worth carefully noting, for it has been neglected to a remarkable degree. It is from this that you obtain in Parisian history the attempts at a democracy based upon representation; it is from this, again, that the principal modern changes in her judicial methods are drawn ; and so curiously strong has been the attraction of English systems for a certain kind of miud in Paris, that even the experiment of aristocracy and of its mask — a limited monarchy — has been tried in these uncongenial surround- ings. The greatest of the men of '93 regrets the English alliance. Mirabeau bases half his public action upon his memories of the English Whigs. Lamartine delights in calling England the Marvellous Island.

And, if we go a little deeper than historical facts and examine those subtle influences of climatic condition (which, as they are more mysterious, so also are of greater

INTRODUCTION 31

import than obvious things), we shall find Paris balanced between the two great zones of Europe. It is hard to say whether she is within or without the belt of vineyards ; a little way to the south and to the east you find the grapes ; a little way to the north and west, to drink wine is a luxury, and the peasants think it a mark of the southerner. There are days in Chevreuse, in the summer, when a man might believe himself to be in a Mediterranean valley, and, again, the autumn and the winter in the great forest of Marly are impressions purely of the north. The Seine is a river that has time and again frozen over, and the city itself is continually silent under heavy falls of snow. Yet she has half the custom of the south, her life is in the open air, her houses are designed for warmth and for sunlight ; she has the gesture and the rapidity of a warmer climate.

For one period of its history you might have called Paris a great northern city, when it was all Gothic and deeply carved, suited to long winter nights and to weak daylight. But in the course of time it has seemed partly to regain the traditions of the Mediterranean, so that you have shallow mouldings, white stone and open streets, standing most often under a grey sky, which should rather demand pointed gables and old deep thoroughfares. The truth is that she is neither northern nor southern, but, in either climate (they meet in her latitude) an exile, satisfying neither, and yet containing both of the ends between which Europe swings ; so that, in all that is done within Paris, you are at a loss whether to look for influence coming up from the Mediterranean, or to listen for the steep waves and heavy sweeping tides of the Narrow Seas. Only with one part of Europe — a part which may later

32 PARIS

transform or destroy the west-^ske has no sympathy ; I mean that which lies to the east of the Elbe. She was a town of the Empire, and the darker and newer part of Europe is as much a mystery to her as to the nations which are her neighbours.

If you will notice her iirst prominence, you wUl discover that Paris rises upon Europe just where the modern period begins. It is as a town of the lower Empire, of the decline, of the barbarian invasions, of the advent of Christianity, that Paris first becomes a great city ; just as the civilization to which we belong starts out upon its adventures; and her history at once assumes that character upon which these paragraphs insist. She receives the barbarian ; the mingled language is talked in her streets ; her palace is the centre of a Teutonic satrapy, which has carved its province out of the Empire ; of the two extremes, she seems to combine either experience. She does not lose her language (like the Ehine valley), nor her religion and customs (like Britain) ; but, on the other hand, she is strongly influenced by the Conquest, and knows nothing of that perfect, lingering Eoman civilization, almost untouched by the invader, which left to Nimes, Aries, and the southern cities a municipal organization lasting to our own day. At the outset of her history she includes the experience of the south and of the north.

During the Carlovingian epoch she loses her place for a time; but, with the rise of the nationalities that follows it, and with the invasions, she is not only intimately concerned but again furnishes the example of which I have been speaking. She sustains siege after siege ; like the Europe of which she is the type, she finally,

INTRODUCTION 33

but with great pain, beats off the pirates, and within her walls rises the first, and what is destined to be the most complete type of the national kingships. The Eobertian House was neither purely feudal nor a mere reminiscence of Imperial power ; it was a mixture of both those elements. It was founded by a local leader who had defended his subjects in the " dark century," and in so much it attaches closely to the feudal character; on the other hand, its members are consecrated kings ; they have the aim of a united and centralized power, and in this they hold even more than do the Ottos to the Imperial memory.

Note how, as Europe develops, the experience of Paris sums up that of the surrounding peoples. The Eoman law finds her an eager listener, but it does not produce in her case the rapid effect which you may notice in some of the Italian cities. Custom weighs hard in the northern town, and Philip Augustus, after all his conquests, could never hear the language which the men trained at Bologna used to Barbarossa just before his defeat. On the other hand, the power of the king which that law was such a powerful agent to increase, was not destined to suffer from repeated reaction as it did in England, and the kings of Paris never fell beneath a direct victory of aristocracy such as that which crushed John at Eunnymede, and centuries later destroyed the Stuarts.

The struggle between government and feudalism was destined to last much longer in France than it did in the neighbouring countries, and as it continued Paris witnessed all its principal features, and the crown finally triumphed only in that same generation of the seventeenth century which saw the complete success of the aristocracy in England and in the Empire.

D

34 PARIS

In the matter of religion the experience of Paris has been equally typical. She heard the first changes of the tweKth century ; the schoolmen discussed in her Univer- sity ; Thomas Aquinas sat at table with her king. When the sixteenth century shook and split the unity of Christendom, its treble aspect was vividly reflected in Paris. The Evangelical, the Catholic, and the Humanist are represented distinctly and in profusion there ; for it is in Paris that Calvin indoctrinates, and Eabelais is read, and, finally, that the St. Bartholomew is seen. She does not, like England, change her creed at the word of a dynasty, nor is she swept by the same purely religious zeal for reform that covers Geneva and so much of Holland ; nor does she stamp out the new movement with the ease of the Italian or the Spaniard ; but all the powers of the time seem to concentrate in her, and, as she has always done, she pays heavily for being the centre of European discussion. The appeal with her (as elsewhere) is to arms, and the struggle is still continuing imder Louis XIV., when its importance wanes before the rise of a rationalism around which the future battles of her religious world will be fought.

This is always the lesson of her history and the way we should read it if we wish to understand. We are looking down into a little space where all our society is working out its solutions. Whether we dwell upon the Gothic Paris of Louis XL, fixing nationality and centralized government, or upon the Paris of '93 — cutting once for all the knot of eighteenth-century theories — or the Paris of '48, where the old political and the new economic problems met; or upon the Paris of 1871, where the older social forces and the love of country just managed to defeat the

INTRODUCTION 35

revolt of the new proletariat — in whatever aspect or at whatever time, she is always the picture of Europe ; the figures struggling in the nations around her show in her small, bright mirror, prismatic and with strange colours, but not distorted. It is in this character that her history- will be most easy of comprehension and will leave with us an impression of greatest meaning.

But whenever we think of the city we do well to remember Mirabeau : " Paris is a Sphinx, I will drag her secret from her;" but in this neither he nor any other man has succeeded.

36 PARIS

CHAPTER II

THE PLAIN OF PARIS

To understand the physical history of a city it is necessary to begin with a knowledge of its geography. And to know the geography of a city a certain method must be pursued, which I shall attempt to hold to in this chapter. In the pursuance of that method there will appear, of necessity, a certain amount of description overlapping that already given in the last chapter ; and much that will be contained in this sketch of the plain of Paris will have to be said over again and emphasized when we come to the history of the city, the story of its separate buildings, the development of its area, and the gradual enlargement of its boundaries. It is at the risk, then, of some repetition that I shall present in the present chapter the character of the territory over which Paris has spread.

As one follows the river Seine from its mouth up to the inland provinces, one discovers for the first hundred and forty miles of its course a certain uniform character, almost unknown in England, and not over common even on the western continent. The river winds in a series of vast loops, a simple system undisturbed by minor turns, and broken only by a long straight reach at Vernon, and a shorter one at Mantes. In less than a dozen of these

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 37

great reaches the river covers the space between Paris and the sea. But the loops are for the greater part so sharp and elongated that the distance as the crow flies from the origin of this formation to the estuary is little more than half the number of miles covered by the river. These great loops run in a clearly defined valley bounded on either side by a chalky and usually well-wooded table- land some three to four hundred feet above the stream, and the slopes by which one reaches it are uniform and very steep, sometimes even (as at les Andelys) breaking into white cliffs. This valley, though it narrows near Vernon, is commonly, both above and below that town, from five to ten miles wide ; it is perfectly flat, and has for its surface a very rich alluvial soil, chiefly laid out in pastm'es. The walls of the valley are, as a rule, unbroken, save where some small tributary comes in by a steep ravine, and the conformation remains the same until one reaches the mouth of the Oise.

At this point, though the river still continues to sweep northward and southward in long stretches, the aspect of the landscape is changed by the lack of continuity in the eastern hills : the tableland on this side breaks up, and the last spur takes the form of a sharp, isolated hog-back known as the hills of Enghien.

On the western side, however, the wooded wall of the Seine valley continues unaltered and remains overhanging the river more or less closely till, at a point twenty-five miles above the mouth of the Oise, and over forty by river, we reach the confluence of the Marne. Here the hills give way on the western side as they had previously done on the eastern, a confused plain marks the central water- shed of northern France, and in its upper reaches the

38

PARIS

Seine becomes but one of many similar streams (the Aube, the Yonne, etc.,) which spread out to their sources in the fields of the rolling country like the last tendrils of a vine. The whole scheme of the lower river presents, there- fore, something of the appearance shown in this sketch —

where the shading represents the high land.

As for the geological character of this valley, and of the plain of Paris at its head, I have not sufficient knowledge of the matter to give it in any detail, nor is it of sufficient importance in such a book as this to merit a very special mention. The valley is clearly a valley ;of erosion and cuts through a 'secondary formation which is cretaceous in its lower parts, and merges gradually into the harder Jurassic rocks as one goes up river. These rocks are of importance in the history of the town, for the places where they crop out from the plain or have been laid bare by erosion have furnished since Eoman times the quarries of hard building stone upon which the permanent beauty of the city so largely depends. The rock is peculiarly hard ia the neighbourhood of and beneath Paris itself, so that, as at Eheims, the material

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 39

of the town has been largely drawn from its own founda- tions in the soil.

Before I leave the valley as a whole to speak of the particular site of the city, there is one last aspect upon which I woxild touch. The military position of Paris in history is determined largely by the contour of this valley and the nature of the uplands. The valley of the Seine is a kind of road leading directly up to Paris, and serves in the strategic history of the city these two purposes : it is an avenue of attack for northern enemies, a lane of reinforcement (if it can be kept open) against enemies from the east; but its importance in either case is not appreciated by so general a statement — there must be read in conjunction with it the concomitant geographical conditions which have made the head of the lower Seine valley the scene of so many fights.

First, the basin in which Paris lies is a converging point for all the small rivers of the watershed — the Yonne, the Aube, the upper Seine ; for the great valley of the Marne, which is the road from the Ehine, and practically for the Oise also, which is the road from Picardy and the flats of Holland.

Secondly, these converging lines of river have a character which is not obvious at the first glance to the modern reader of historical geography. These rivers — all navigable for shallow craft, all bordered by rich alluvial fields, aU equable in their supply, and all furnished with neighbouring slopes for terrace cultivation — were the first roads, and supported the first settlements. It was along their courses that the earliest groups of Gaulish huts would gather, and therefore they became in time a kind of skein, upon whose threads the great towns were strung like beads.

40 PARIS

Thirdly, the upper plateaux were — and still largely are — densely wooded, poorly watered, and, comparatively, more thinly populated.

Fourthly, these various converging lines do not meet in some vague and open champaign ; you do not get re- produced here the conditions so commonly seen in military geography, where a number of rivers meet in a wide field, and furnish a huge arena for a hundred battles. On the contrary, the stream of any invasion is broken sharply by a screen of steep hills on the south and west, behind which lie great stretches of woodland. Therefore the head of the lower Seine valley has become a kind of pool, where the iuvasions meet with their final shock, and eddy round the walls of the city, to flood it ia the event of success, or to wash back from it like a tide in the event of failure.

Now, putting all these conditions together, the strategic position of Paris is plain. An army must push on from one advanced base after another ; it needs water, roads, and towns ; sometimes walls. Therefore we see the Norsemen of the ninth century, the Normans of William and Henry I., the English, of Edward III. and Henry V., the Girondin rebels of '93, all attacking by way of the Seine valley; down the Oise or the Marne come the succession of German invasions; from the Yonne the Eomans. For once that Paris has been attacked or relieved from the south and west, it has been so approached ten times from the north- west or the east. And all this is partly true even of modem times. The great bases of supply still lie on the rivers ; the main railroads for the most part follow the valleys.

After this general view of the valley and basin in

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 41

which Paris lies, let me turn to a more particular de- scription of the actual site of the city.

It is just below the confluence of the Marne, at a point where the western wall of the valley is gradually falling, and where the eastern wall has already disappeared in a wide plain, that Paris has grown. It has spread partly over the spurs of the range on the southern bank, but mainly over the flat country that characterises the northern, and has been all through its history essentially a. city built on a plain, though its surface is diversified by one or two sharp hiUs.

If the reader will amplify the sketch which I am about to attempt, by following its details upon the shaded map opposite these words, he will be able to obtain a general impression of features which it is necessary to retain as he follows the history of the town ; but I must add, before beginning my description, that the islands, the marshes, and occasionally the sides of a hill, have been modified by human action as the city has grown. What I have here represented is the original appearance of the country-side over which Paris has been built.

The central feature in the space of somewhat over a hundred square miles which the map covers is the river Seine, whose course for a matter of twenty to twenty-four miles runs through the centre of the plan, and forms, as it were, the base round which the contours of the neighbour- hood can be built up. The river (which runs, of course, along the line of least elevation) enters the map by the lower right-hand corner, a point where, at the normal summer height, the surface is about a hundred feet above sea level ; it leaves the map at the upper edge, just to the left of the middle, and has there fallen to a trifle under

42 PARIS

ninety feet. As for the small section that reappears in the extreme north-west, we ne6d pay no attention to it ; it is an accident necessitated by the shape of the map, and represents a reach very distant from the site with which we are dealing.

The first thiag we notice, then, with regard to the Seiae at this point is its elevation above sea-level, for this gives a base-liae from which to measure the surrounding lulls. I may mention, for the sake of illustration, that, far inland as Paris is, the river is no higher at this point than is the Thames at Henley.

The next poiat to be observed is the slight fall of the Seine in this part of its course. There are seasons, after heavy rains or during the melting of the snow in early spring, when the current is swift enough to impede the traffic up river ; but these seasons are rare, and even before the stream was locked, merchandise could pass up or down with almost eq[ual facility. It is this feature iu the Seine which has given its commercial and military history so different a character to that of the Ehone valley, and made Paris such a contrast to Lyons.

Thirdly, the river is deep.^ No ford is found for many miles up stream. The pirate boats of the ninth century (it is true they were of light draught) could sail right up to the city, as their contemporaries could force the Yare up to Norwich; and even to-day you may see at the northern quay under the Louvre a steamer that comes to Paris weekly from Southampton**.

If, after noting these characters of the river, we glance

' The minimum depth below Paris is now ten feet, but eyen before the modem dredging it was nowhere under six.

[Where olil street'! colnculo with modem it has been practically Irapoasihle to mark both. I have made an attx^mpt at this, however, in the case of the Kue St. Martin. A few moiteni bulldlntrs and squai'cs are refen"e<l to letters, in onler to give some clue t<i the general scope of the map.]

MODERN

A.

Tlie Bom-8c.

Q. Institute and Mazarin Libraiy.

B.

riucc lies Victoiies.

H. Bridge, Place and (juay of the

C.

PalnU Royal.

Hotel de Ville.

DD

. Hnlles.

' K. Place des Vosgea.

E.

I.oiivre.

L. Place do la Ripublique.

FF

Peint Neaf.

MEDIAEVAL

1.

Ste. Agiii^B (Inter St. Eustnche).

32. Abbey and Church of Ste. Genevieve.f

2.

The 01.1 Holies.

33. St. Etienne du Mont.

3.

Cenieter.v of the Imiocentf*.

34. OolK'ge lie Cholets.

4.

St. Thoinns ilii Louvre.

3.'). College Montnigu.

6.

The Louvre.

30. College des LombanKf

e.

St. Nieholas du Louvre.

37. College de8,Gi-ossins.t

7.

Hfytel Bourbon (nuil Ganlena).

3». CoUSge de Benuvnis.t

K.

St. Geminin l'Auxerroi9.t

39. The Carmelites.

9.

The ChiUcIct.

40. The Bernadins.

10.

The Pont au Change.

41. College Canlinal Lemoine.t

11.

St. Barthamy.

42. Bona Enfnnts.

12.

Palais (le la Citi.f

43. St. Julicn Ic Pau\Te.»

13.

St. Genuain <les Prt-s.!

44. Bishop's Palace.

U.

Tonr anil Hotel de Nesle.

46. Notre Dame.*

1.').

The Augustinians.

46. Catheilral Close.

16.

St. AniW lies Arts.

47. Hotel Dieu.

17.

Colltge Mignon.t

4». St. Symphorien.

IK.

College lie Tonrs.

49. St. Denis de la Chartre.

10.

St. Severin.*

50. Pont Mibray (or Notre Dame).

SO.

Petit Pont.

51. St. MeiTi.

21.

Petit Chiltelet.

52. Maison aux Piliei-s.

SS.

Olil St. Sulpiee.

63. St. Jean.

23.

College lie Bourgogne.

54. St. Gervais,'

24.

0ordelier8.t

55. Convent of Ste. Catherine.

2«.

College d'Hapoourt.

56. Hotel and Pare des Toumelles.

26.

Hatel de Oluuy.o

57. BastiUe.

27.

Colleges de Bayeux and de Rlieini!<.

5S. Church of St. Paul.

28.

Oolltge de Oluny.

69. Hfitel St. Paul.

29.

Sorbonne.t

60. Celestins.

30.

Jacobins (of St. Jacques).

61. Abtey of St. Martin.+

31.

Parloir aux Bourgeois.

62. Temple.

[Tlio wall of Philip Augustus and the northern, outer, wall of Charles V., are Tml marked by any number ; neither are the gates, nor the streets. I have also oudtted many sites (such as St. Laurent, St. Magloire,etc.) for fear of over-burdening the map. Such buildings as remain in their entirety are marked with an asteiisk (•) ; those of which a part remains, with a dagger (f).]

MEDIAEVAL PARIS.

( liarJy Middle Ages. ■■ Laltr Middle Axes. ..

.Modem Work.

[To/ooep. 224.

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 43

at its general direction and note the lie of the hills about it, we get some such impression as follows : —

The river, entering the plain of Paris from the south- east, makes, first of all, a curve like a great bow, roughly- semicircular va. shape, and with a chord running nearly east and west. This bow takes up a matter of eight or niae nules, and when it has come to its extreme southern limit the river turns abruptly round, and runs ia a north- easterly direction till it passes the northern boundary of the map. This is the first of those great loops which, as was said at the head of this chapter, are characteristic of the lower course of the Seine ; and were we to follow the river beyond our present plan, we should find it cover- ing the next forty miles in a succession of long reaches, running thus to the south-west, and turning sharply again to the north-east alternately.

The hills upon either side of the stream present very different systems; on the south and west there runs a more or less continuous range, which is the last of that plateau whose escarpments I have mentioned above as forming the walls of the valley. Their height is from three to four hundred feet above the river, and it is evident that they determine its course, for it is a northern pro- jection of theirs in the middle of the map that forms the central "bow," and their steep sides on the western boundary that deflect the river northwards in its great loop.

With regard to these hills on the left bank of the Seine there are a couple of points which are of special importance.

Pirst, there must be noted very especially that sharp hill, connected with the plateau by a vague and broad ridge, and standing steeply above the river, just south of

44 PARIS

the group of islands that marks the middle of the map. It is not very high — ^less than a hundred and fifty feet above the water — but it has always made a peculiar feature in the landscape of Paris. It is the old " Mons Lncotitius," on whose slopes the Eoman Emperor's palace and the Amphitheatre were built: its summit was the site of the Eoman camp, later, of the great Basilica of the Apostles, and of the tomb of Ste. G-enevieve. Since the twelfth century it has been the hill of the University, and it remains to-day, with its group of schools, the quarter of Paris which is next in order of historical importance to the island of Cite.

Secondly, the reader should pay a particular attention to the belt of plain which runs south and west of this hill, growing narrower till it ends in a mere strip between the steep slopes and the sharp bend of the river. This is the plain of Issy. Though now all but covered with the houses of the town and its suburbs, it was for many centuries the granary of Paris, and notably under the Eoman domination it was an imperial estate, serving as endowment partly to the expenses of Lutetia and partly to the fisc.

It may be well, before leaving the left bank, to mention the little river Bievre, which runs from the middle of the southern edge of our map, and falls into the Seine just above the central group of islands. The Bievre forms one of those ravines of which mention was made above as cutting through the plateaux of the lower Seine, and another smaller valley — that of the rivulet of Sevres — may be seen on the western side of my plan. It has a certain historical importance, because there runs along it the main road to Versailles.

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 45

Turning now to the right bank there wUl be discovered a very different kind of country. There comes first a mass of confused rolling land, none of it very high. It is cut by the valley of the Marne, which may be seen entering the map on the lower eastern side, and falling into the Seine some three or four miles lower down. This river is, of course, very closely connected with the history of the city, but it would only confuse the present descrip- tion to insist upon more than these salient points. First, it was the natural highway by which commerce could reach the fertile plains of northern Champagne; secondly, as we shall see later, its valley formed the route of invasion for any attack leading from the Ehine into northern Gaul.

It is with the country on the right bank immediately below the mouth of the Marne, with that part, in other words, which stands north of the " bow " of the river, that we are more immediately concerned. For it is over this that the living part — the palaces and the main thorough- fares— of mediaeval and modern Paris has grown up.

A feature that will immediately strike one is a kind of ridge or mound running in a half-circle from the con- fluence of the two rivers to a point some seven or eight mQes lower down stream, where it falls abruptly upon the Seine just at the place where the great bow begins to bend southward, and where a long, straight island stands in the middle of the reach.

This rising ground is roughly semicircular in shape, and encloses between itself and the river a crescent-shaped plain. It rises at three points (namely, at its eastern and western extremities and at its most northern outer part) into three well-defined summits. Of these the fiirst and second are of no great height. That on the eastern side

46 PARIS

furnishes the hills of Menilmontant, the Buttes Chaumont and Pere la Chaise. It has been for many hundred years the principal quarry of stone for Paris, and is now the densest industrial quarter in the capital. That on the west is the site of the great new private houses; it is the wealthy quarter marked by the Arc de Triomphe on the one end of its ridge, and by the Trocadero overlooking the river on the other.

The first of these makes some impression on the land- scape, the second very little ; but by far the most striking feature in this haK-circle of rising ground is the central hiU on the north. It is much higher not only than any other summit of the ridge, but than any part of Paris, and it dominates the modern city from within in a way which I believe to be unique among the principal towns of Europe. I shall allude to it so often in the course of this book, and my readers will so often find it a standpoint from which a general view of the plain below may be had at some particular moment in history, that it would be well to fix upon it with especial care. It is the old hill of the Temples of Mercury and Mars, which has during the Christian centuries been a place sacred to St. Denis, and which still keeps his name and the nature of his death in its title of " Montmartre."

We may now summarize this description of the con- figuration of the country, and say that Paris stands in the midst of a river-valley some hundred feet above the sea, and at a spot some hundred miles distant from it ; that this valley is here bounded on the left bank by a plateau of from three to four hundred feet in height, while on its right bank it develops into a wide plain, a portion of which, close to the river, is enclosed by a semicircular ridge, rising

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 47

in its central portion, where it is most distant from the stream, into a conspicuous conical hill.

Let me now turn to the physical features which must be clearly grasped if we are to follow the growth of the town. First of these comes the group of islands which will be found almost in the exact centre of the map, and a little to the right of the northernmost point of that great " bow " in the Seine to which such frequent allusion has been made.

Such islands are a peculiar mark of the northern French rivers : the Oise, the Mame, the Seiue, the Loire are full of them. They are much larger and much more numerous than those of our English streams ; for while the Thames has on the whole but few, and the Severn hardly any, it is difficult to remember a single reach of the navigable Seiae in which they do not appear. Nearly always fiat, very fertile, ringed commonly with willow, and often graced by tall poplars, they form so many little isolated farms, and have been inhabited and tilled from the earliest years.

The particular island from which Paris grew, and on which the first rough bunch of savage huts were built, is one of a group somewhat remarkable among its neighbours. An island in the Seine is ordinarily very long and narrow, and often follows in its shape the course of the river. One succeeds another in a kind of procession, and several examples of this may be found even upon the short stretch of river included in our plan. But the group which was the germ of Lutetia is formed of a cluster of islands, each short and broad, while the river is widened so considerably at the place where they stand that it seems to have stretched its banks in order to admit them.

48

PARIS

If the formation of this group be glanced at in the accompanying sketch, it will be seen that there are three large islands almost overlapping each other. The largest and westernmost of these (the one lying to the left of the

sketch) is the Island of Lutetia. For the first fifteen of its twenty centuries of history it alone of the three was in- habited, and to this day it alone of the three sites possesses any historical importance.

Of the first two there is nothing much to be said in this general description. The easternmost has been joined to the right bank during our own time, and forms the modern Quai Henri IV. and its neighbouring streets. The middle island may or may not have been bisected by a narrow ditch — it is an interesting matter, and one which, for the sake of simplicity, I have omitted to discuss. It is upon the third that one's attention should alone be fixed.

The first point which a modern reader acquainted with Paris will remark is the unfamiliar presence of three small islets surrounding it, one like a long strip on the south, and two side by side at the very end of the Isle de la Cite. They are not to be seen to-day. The former was absorbed long ago in the Quai des Orffevres, the latter in the Place

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 49

Dauphine, aud there has been added in this way about one eighth to the too crowded and exiguous acreage of the larger island. The Isle de la Cite has similarly grown slightly on the northern bank by the building of the quays, and very largely at its eastern extremity ; for the garden of Notre Dame and the point on which the Morgue stands are nearly all new land. As for the measurements of the island, they were, to be exact, 700 yards long by 280 broad, or, say about the same size as the park and spaces between the Horse-guards and Buckingham Palace in London. Another detail worth noting is that the level of the pave- ment upon it has been raised some six or seven feet since medieval, and presumably a little more since Eoman, times.

To return to the general view of our matter ; the growth of the city, proceeding from this nucleus, would naturally be in suburbs upon either bank. It wiU be seen in this book how the Southern Hill became during the Eoman period its principal outlet. The late Mr. Grant Allen has well observed that in a time when civilization came from the south the city of necessity " looked southward " — as for that matter did Lincoln and Lyons, and as Nimes looked along her metropolitan road — so for many centuries this annex was the more important addition to the original town on the island. Here were the palace, the quarries, the camp, the circus, the quay, and later the great suburban church and shrine of the Saint. It is to be remarked that the southern extension was easy and profitable, for the soil was firm, the great Eoman road traversed the suburb, and the whole lay in the neighbourhood of that narrow fertile plain on the left bank which was the granary of the city.

Nevertheless, the main expansion of Paris has been to

E

so PARTS

the north since the revival of civilization, and here very for- midable obstacles seemed to threaten the growth of the city.

Between the river and the semicircular ridge of hills which I have described above, lay, at the eastern end of the plain, a great marsh. We know that a Eoman suburb existed just north of the island, and that villas were scattered about the plain ; we know also that two good Eoman roads branched out over this space, and all this might be used to prove that Eome had partially drained the fen during the many centuries of her rule. Whether she did so or not, it certainly reappeared in the Middle Ages, and it was only finally disposed of in that great expansion of the twelfth century which was like a new birth for Paris.

Another obstacle to the northern growth of the town was the stream that led from this marsh to the river. It will be seen on the map running just north of and almost parallel to the Seine, falling iuto it at last a mile or so below the group of islands. This little stream (whose old name of Menilmontant came from the hill above its source) was insignificant in itself, and would hardly have checked the builders of a suburb, had it not been followed on either side by a belt of treacherous soil similar to that in which it took its rise. It was not till Philip Augustus, in draining the marsh, deepened and canalized this rivulet that the ground about its course became firm enough for building on; and though he succeeded, it was two full centuries before even the upper part of this stream was covered in with houses. To-day it gives, by its slight depression, the central line for the drainage of the modern town.^

' This line runs from the Place de la Republique a little north of

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 51

To these primitive obstacles or defences that surrounded the town we must add the woods. Paris did not grow out to meet them till a quite recent period, and a great part of her outlying forest stUl remains. In the first physical aspect of the place, with which this chapter mainly deals, they were the principal mark of the landscape. The southern and western outlying hills were, of course, covered with forests, as they are at this time ; but even on the site of what is now Paris two great groups of woodland extended. One spread eastward from the marsh over the high ground indefinitely into the valley of the Marne. It would, were it marked on our map, go up to and beyond the right hand border. Its relics are found to-day in the wood and park of Vincennes. The other filled all the narrow loop made by the sharp course of the river on the left of the map, crossed the neighbouring horn of the semicircular ridge, and ended at or about the banks of the little stream of Menilmontant. Its remains to-day in the Bois de Boulogne and in the few remaining trees of the Champ Elysees. These two forests probably failed to meet to the north. Montmartre and the plain at its base were presumably bare even at the outset of our history.

All this, then, is the physical nature of the site upon which Paris lies. It wiU now be possible to carry through the reading of this book a clear impression of the character and locality of the many points with which the history of the town is bound up. We know the Island of the Cite, with its little accompanying islets; the two prin- cipal islands just above it in the stream ; the famous hUl

the main Boulevard. It passes south of the St. Lazaie station, and follows the Bue de la Boetie to the river, which it reaches just below the Pont de I'Alma.

52 PARIS

of the University immediately to the south and connected by its broad ridge with the outlying plateau; the river Bievre upon one side of it, the fertile belt of Issy on the other. On the north we have fixed the great hill of Mont- martre, the ridge spreading on either side of it with its heights on the west of Chaillot ; on the east of the Buttes Chaumont, of Pere la Chaise, and of Menilmontant, the stream which took its name from this last, and which rose in the great marsh whose memory stiU survives in the quarter of the Marais. These names and positions meet one continually throughout the story of Paris ; and, as I said at the opening of this chapter, it is essential to any exact knowledge of this story, that one shoiild plough through the detail of a map whose interest cannot arise until one is further acquainted with the city.

Nevertheless, it may be very justly maintained that an accumulation of names and geographical details, how- ever useful for reference, is of little value as a graphic representation. It is not only the map, it' is the picture which is a necessity to the reader of such a book as this ; I will therefore attempt to give some sketch of the im- pression which all this circle of Mil, plain, and river would have made upon the eye before the landscape was confused with houses.

For this purpose I will imagine a Gaulish boatman, one perhaps of the association which we may presume to have existed even before the Eomans came ; and he shall be rowing down stream with his merchandise in one of those light-draught vessels which later Labienus captured. He shall have started (let us say) from Melun, and for a whole day he has followed the slow stream as it ran, with but few windings, to the north-west. The land about him

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 53

was flat, with here and there a low-terraced rise just be- yond the banks of the river. Forests sometimes came right down to the water, and sometimes — especially as he passed the mouth of the Orge — a wide marsh would merge with the shore and hide the plain with reeds. It would be in the middle of the second day of his journey that he would come upon the Marne, much wider than the little streams he had passed, flowing in from the east, and forming with the upper Seine a new and broader river. Just at the confluence of these two streams, from the point of the little cape where there stood the shrine of the water-god, he would note some change in the landscape. To the left hills of a certain height made a line upon the horizon, and a spur of these ran out and touched the river some three miles below him ; while on the right, and in front of him, he would catch sight, beyond the river banks, of isolated points of high land ; the highest of these would stand flve miles away — a bare conical hill crowned with a grove.

As he fell down stream the river would begin to turn a little to the left from its old direction, and to flow more and more westward, till, just at the point where it ran under the slopes of the southern spur, and after he had passed the marshy mouth of the Bievre, he would come upon a group of three large islands. The two first of these he would leave upon his right. They were reedy and uninhabited, and they had no shore for his boat. But right before him he would notice the third, lying in mid- stream, and would know that he had come to the end of his journey. On the eastern end of the island (the point that he was approaching) was a little altar to the river- god ; behind it he could make out a number of scattered

54 PARIS

huts, and on either side the two branches of the stream were crossed by a high narrow bridge of logs laid on many- trestles.

He had a choice of two places in which to beach his boat — one on either side of the broader northern branch of the river. That on the main shore was larger than the small island landiag-place, and we will suppose that he there drew up his shallow boat and crossed round by the bridge on to the island. The view that he would then have gained from some high point — one of those wooden watch towers, for instance, which the Gauls bxiilt in times of danger — must have been something of this kind.

On the little island immediately at his feet lay the group of huts, and at its western end the rough gardens, while narrow sluggish ditches cut off a little strip of land from its southern side, and two small patches from its western poiat ; a rough track joined its two bridges, and a kind of ill-defined square or trodden green lay just between them — a place for council, and perhaps for market.

To the south and to the west ran a continual range of hills, all covered with deep forests, so that the place was silent and lonely ; and under the shadow of these lay the river in a great bend. That part of it which he had just descended ran off in a nearly straight reach to the mouth of the Marne. He noted the sharp ravine of the Bievre falling into it nearly at his feet; its lower course bent more and more southerly tiU it touched the hills, and then swept northward in a sudden curve whose course he could follow here and there miles away between the trees. Just opposite Mm rose the steep low hill that seemed a spur of the main range, and over it ran from the southern

THE PLAIN OF PARIS 55

bridge the little rough road that bound the village to the richer country far off on the Loire. He could see this little road going straight over the brow of the hill till it passed into the thick woods beyond. To the right of this hill, and still immediately below him, ran the only belt of cultivated land in all the landscape. It broadened out along the bank of the river, and he would follow the fields with his eyes to a point where, much farther down the stream, the forest came down from the heights, and hemmed them in.

On the immediate north of him there lay nothing but a waste of marsh and common, across which the road to the coast picked its way in a long curve ; and beyond this flat, with its vivid green of fen-land on the right, and its bare, chalky common on the left, he saw a low ring of hills running from the mouth of the Marne out to the north, and coming back to the river some two miles below him. Here and there upon this high ground he could distinguish some summit. But the point on which his eye immedi- ately rested was the most distant edge of this half circle, where, some three miles to the north, rose a conspicuous and isolated hill, far higher than anything but the distant ranges. At the summit of its steep and bare sides was the sacred grove, and he knew that there also the Parisii climbed to the sacrifice.

For the rest, to the right and to the left of fen and common there were only endless woods going out to the horizon.

This large hollow of deep woods and marsh and open scrub, with its half-deserted pathway, its broad, slow river, its reeds and willow-banks, its little island village, must have struck a chance traveller from the more populous

56 PARIS

plains of the centre or the Loire with a sense of loneliness. It lay remote from the routes of Gaul, it was but the central refuge of an inferior tribe ; and in all its horizon of forest and common there was but one small strip of harvest. Perhaps the eye could distinguish among the distant trees in the west a rare line of smoke, where some hamlet sheltered itself in the ravine of Sevres, or under the slope of Meudon ; but in general this country-side, which time had set apart for such great work, must have carried on into the beginning of its history an impression of isolation and of silence.

( 57 )

CHAPTEE III

LUTETIA

Now that we have seen on what a site Paris is to stand, the island that will be its root, the hills that wiU bound it, and the marshy northern plain over which it is destined to spread, we can turn to the positive history of the town whose setting and mould we have determined.

In this first division of the story of the city it is the scanty tradition of the Gaulish village and the somewhat fuller details of the Eoman town that must form my subject. As to the period covered, it stretches from the conquest of Csesar to the death of Ste. Genevieve, but in all this long space of over five centuries there is so little written down that it is permissible to give a sketch of it within the limits that a chapter of such a book as this imposes. Paris during the first part of this period re- mained a small and comparatively unimportant provincial town; though it rose in the fourth century to a higher position, and though the emperors had begun to make it their residence, it yet preserved an undecided place, until, during the convulsion of the fifth, a space of time which the life of Ste. Genevieve exactly covers, the Prankish conquest introduced its greater fortunes as the capital of

58 PARIS

northern Gaul. When, partly through the imperial tradition, partly by the accident of a line of march, Clovis entered the city, and when later he buried the great Patroness upon the southern hill, the new character of Paris was fixed. It is therefore to this point in the year 509 that I shall follow in the present chapter what little is certainly known of the origins of the town.

But these five hundred years and more divide them- selves into two very distinct parts. There is first a matter of some three centuries, during which, though Paris is obscure, the details of Eoman life as a whole are as clearly and positively known as those of our own time. They are necessarily less numerous than those upon which we buUd a modern record, but they are well attested and unmixed with legend. As to the remaining time, roughly the fourth century and the fifth, the decay of the whole civilization affects this department of letters, and such accounts as we have tend, especially as the end of the Eoman dominion approaches, to be confused and over- personal, or to be rendered doubtful by an insistence upon the marvellous. To these qualities of the later records another drawback must be admitted : the presence of contemporary authorities is rare. Thus, the life of St. Marcel is written two hundred years after his death ; the chronicle upon which we most depend (that of St. Gregory of Tours) is concerned here with a period of which he was not an eye-witness — Ste. Genevieve died a full generation before he was born. Unfortunately, it is in the nature of our history that these more uncertain writers should be ampler than the earlier authorities. They were writing of a time when Paris first began to fill a great place in Gaul; their predecessors had nothing to say of a little

LUTETIA 59

island-town that was for so long a mere dependent upon Sens, smaller than Orleans, less of a centre than Chartres.

The first mention in history of the people and the island is in Cassar's description of his Gallic wars. The passage directly concerning them is short. There was no intention to fix the mind of the reader upon a site the mention of which was incidental only to his general policy and the campaigns that followed upon it. But by a comparison with what we know of the semi-civilization to which it belonged, we can fill in something of the outline he gives us, and on the analogy of other centres placed somewhat in the same surroundings we can obtain a fairly accurate impression of what was meant by the group of Gaulish huts from the centre of which he harangued the assembled tribes.

In some matter upon which history is sUent and ethnography in doubt, the line of the Seine and Marne formed a frontier between the two great divisions of northern Gaul. To these Caesar gives the name of Belgic and Celtic Gaul : the former stretching across the northern plains eastward of the rivers, and reaching the marshes of the low countries; the latter running westward into the broken land of what is now upper Normandy, Brittany, and Maine. There has been an attempt to prove that the contrast was between a Celtic and a Teutonic people; but even were these terms capable of a definition, the evidence is insufficient for any such conclusion. It is enough for our purpose to know that some sharp division existed, and that the Marne and Seine formed a political frontier between the great groups of population. Situate upon that frontier, and even (according to one derivation)

6o PARIS

taking their name from the marches of such a border out- post, lay the Parisii;

The Gaul iato which Caesar entered possessed a character which seems inseparable from early or imperfect civilizations, and which may, among other causes, be traced to lack of communications. It was a loose agglomeration of tribes, each singly strong through a bond of half-fictitious consanguinity, but weak as a confederation from the jealousies of the chiefs and from the lack of any central power. There is no evidence that these tribes had in the past been united in one of those transitory empires that occasionally appear in such a society ; their mutual relations consisted in the continual dependence of the smaller and weaker clans upon the stronger, in loose and imperfect alliances, and occasionally, during a moment of common danger, in some vast but unstable combination. Their skill in so many arts, their dependence upon a large half-servile population, their ill-defined but ardent patriotism bring them nearer perhaps to the Welsh tribal system of the early Middle Ages than to any other of which we have historical evidence.

The Parisii appear, when Csesar found them, to have been driven within the recent memory of living men from some more eastern station. An advance of the Belgic tribes had pushed them back, and they had taken refuge under that powerful nation the Senones, who counted as one of the chief clans of Gaul. It was to these Senones that history or tradition ascribed the great Italian raid of three centuries before; one of the vague, irresistible marches that flood out and return like tides from the French soil and relieve history with such strange accidents as the Crusades or the Eevolutionary wars.

LUTETIA 6 1

The Parisii, holding by a species of tenure from this principal tribe, occupied the plain upon which Paris is built and the western hills. The territory, though vaguely defined, would be limited by the nature of the soil ; fenced in to the east by the great marshes and by the wood of Vincennes, spreading on the western plateau through the contiauous forests that afforded so excellent a retreat, it held a population of some thirty thousand, and furnished a body of eight thousand men to the war levy. This population depended to some extent on unfree labour ; but the number of the servile class cannot have been great in these rough northern boundaries, where the few clearings on the table-land and the firmer parts of the river valleys alone afforded a field for labour. As for their produce, we must believe that they had nothing more than the oats, wheat, and barley that made the wealth of the neighbouring valley of the Loire; and these, as was said in the last chapter, would be found most plentifully between the river and the hills, where the Invalides and the Champ de Mars now stand, on the plain of the left bank that remained for so many centuries the principal granary of the city.

Over this territory, then, was spread the tribe. It covered all the present department of the Seine, a little strip of Seine et Marne, and a wide belt in Seine et Oise ; it gave to the tract the old title of " Parisis," that is found in so many place-names of the neighbourhood, and it became at last that diocese of Paris which, in its hierarchical dependence upon the Archbishopric of Sens, preserved,^ as ecclesiastical institutions must always do, a relic of the original political condition. But throughout Gaul each tribe, though living scattered in its hamlets, possessed also ' That is, up to the great change of 1622.

63 PARIS

a fortified centre, to which the Eoman invaders gave their name of " oppidum." These were not towns or cities, they were villages like the rest, chosen, however, for the strength of their sites. Skilled especially in defensive warfare, the Gauls had it in their military traditions to choose such places upon one of a few simple models ; an escarped plateau, the crest of a sharp isolated hUl, a peninsula, an island in a river, gave the opportunity they required, and it was in these fortified enclosures that the Eomans found a mould ready-made for that municipal civilization which by the previous absorption of so many city-states had become the basis of their empire.

As has been seen in the earlier chapters of this book, it was an island in the Seine that formed the retreat of the Parisii and their fortress in time of war. It has been argued that the site had special advantages, defended as it was in an especial manner by the reedy mouths of the Orge and the Bievre, and situated on some principal track from the south. These conclusions are quite uncertain ; the plain as a whole was an obvious site, but there seems no particular reason why one island more than another in it should have been chosen. The first wandering inhabitants fixed by accident upon a certain group in this part of the river, they might equally well have settled on any of the dozen or so that marked the course of the river throughout their country. But the group once chosen it was evident that what is now the "Isle de la Cite" would of necessity become the principal or only place of settlement, for its nearness to the southern bank, its steep shores, its size and its broad, even shape lent it especially to the purposes of a defensive settlement. It was here that the circle of huts, such as they were described in the last chapter, arose.

LUTETIA 63

We must imagine them scattered irregularly, but massed especially towards the eastern end of the forty acres or so that formed the whole area of the little kraal, while such gardens as they may have had were grouped on the western part of the island. Down the steep hill in the immediate south would run the first track from the nearest point of the Loire valley, and this track would cross to the island by one of those narrow wooden bridges which the Gauls could build, of which remains may still be found on the AUier, and which furnished the communications of that other island fortress of Melun higher up the river. The track having crossed the narrow left arm of the Seine by this bridge would then continue straight across the island at its broadest part ; one would imagine that it there formed the wide public meeting place of the village. It passed in a straight line over the larger northern arm of the river, and went on northward, curving round the edge of the marsh, leaving the hill of Montmartre on the left, and following finally the direction of Senlis.

All this has been alluded to in the earlier pages of this book, but at the risk of iacluding a little excess of pedantic detail, I would here attempt to determine the exact site of these bridges. It might appear a matter of small moment in so general a history as this, were it not for the great imaginative interest that attaches to the Parisian habit of continuity. I have pointed out in the introductory chapter how symbolic this continuity is of the history of the city ; how, through perpetually changing forms, there endures a spirit and a personality, of which this constantly similar use of certain places — a sacredness of locality as it were — is the outward sign. It is true, as we shall see, of the public worship, of the markets, and of the courts of the

64 PARIS

city ; is it also true of this pre-historic road and its bridges ?

To determine this, it is necessary that I should refer my reader to the sketch map upon p. 98, where the few simple sites of Gallo-Eoman Paris are set down. The point of departure for our inquiry is the road from Genabum (that is, the modern Orleans) and the little southern bridge. With regard to these there is no doubt. There was but one great road from the south ; its known direction, the tombs that (in the Roman fashion) are found to have bordered upon it, the line of the palace which was afterwards built beside it — a continuous tradition, all point to the site of the Petit Pont to-day as being that of the trestle-bridge which was crossed by the assembled tribes as they came in from the Beauce to gather before Caesar, and which in the next year Camulogen burnt to save the town. It is with regard to the northern bridge that doubt has arisen. Its site would be either that of the Pont au Change or of the Pont Notre Dame. Por the former view there are these arguments : that throughout the early Middle Ages the "Grand Pont," that is, the principal bridge, was the Pont au Change ; and we know that at the head of this bridge the great defences of Louis VI. were built. It was, again, the commercial route of the Middle Ages, and even derives its name from this character. A further point that carried some weight with old authorities on Paris was the tradition that the " Chatelet " had its origin in a fort erected by Csesar to defend the northern bridge — and the Chatelet was of course at the head of the Pont au Change. To this tradition, which rises in the very origins of the Middle Ages, a certain reverence should be paid, for though the name of Csesar is so constantly

LUTETIA 65

misapplied by men of that period, it is almost invariably connected with work that is certainly Eoman.

There are, on the other hand, and in favour of the Pont Notre Dame, the following arguments. It is ia a direct line with the Petit Pont, and with the southern road. To make the track cross to the northern shore by the Pont au Change it would be necessary to give it, without any reason, a bend across the island. Savage tracks bend so when there is some physical reason for divergence, but there was here no such accident of the soil, nor was it in the tradition of Eoman engineering to admit this kind of break in direction ; such an example of a turn within the narrow limits of an island would, I think, be imique in Gaul were it true of Paris. It is certainly not found at Melun, nor at Charleville, nor at Eouen, nor at Mantes, nor in any that I know of the Eoman sites of Gaul with which we can compare it. Again, the Gaulish trail to the north round the marsh corresponds with the Pont Notre Dame, not with the Pont au Change. It is true that the latter, if prolonged, would become the main Eoman road to the northern provinces, but there is no trace that the prolongation was ever actually built ; rather the evidences of such scant discoveries as have been made here tend to show that this great north road turned abruptly out of the older lane to Senlis. For, at the spot marked X upon the map a triangular comer of wall has been discovered which marks the junction of the two ways. Finally, though it is a doubtful matter even for experts to determine the age of such a relic, it is certain that the traces of wooden piles in the bed of the river (which traces correspond with the Pont Notre Dame) are much older than the mediaeval bridge that crossed at the same

F

66 PARIS

place. No such piles have been found in any other part of the river near the island.

From a comparison of these arguments, I would conclude that, so far as one may assert in such an uncertain matter, the straight way across the island is that of the old road and its bridges. "When one goes down the hill of the Eue St. Jacques, crosses the Petit Pont, skirts the great, windy square of the Cathedral, and goes over the Pont Notre Dame to follow the narrow Eue St. Martin, one is walking in the track of the rare southern merchants, who, before the Eoman legions came, may have passed and found this little village on their way from the Loire to the lonely harbours of the Somme.

For the rest there is nothing certain with regard to the first origins of the place. Even the name is doubtful. Caesar, from whom we have it first, gives it as "Lutetia," and in this form it has passed into history. But it is uncertain whether this spelling most accurately corresponds to the native name which the Eomans adopted. The hill above the city on the south was always " Mons Lucotitius," and the town itself is " Lucotocia " in Strabo, " Louchetia " in Julian's charming praise of his little capital. We must, however, call it by its more usual name of Lutetia, and that may mean anything you will ; there are a hundred guesses, but the most pleasant is that which makes it " the white town." For even if the name first came from the chalky dust of the plain in summer, it fits very well with the temples and the palace that the Eomans built against the dark water of the river and the shining green of the northern marsh and pasture land. Also, since the Eenaissance, it is a white town that they have been trying to rebuUd.

LUTETIA 67

The village of the Gauls has but two memories attached to it. The first is that of the great meeting which Caesar called in B.o. 53. It is of interest to know that Lutetia was chosen in order to withdraw the assembly from the influence of the centre now called Chartres. He feared this town, which was the natural rallying place of Celtic Gaul, and with which its worship and vague patriotism were connected. He therefore changed the meeting place to the island sixty miles away, where, in what was almost a frontier post for them, lonely and surrounded with woods, he could feel more certain of the influence which his speech would have upon the chiefs. The episode was not peculiar to Lutetia ; it was an accident which might have befallen any of the smaller northern places.

The second incident is far more a part of its individual history, for it is the prototype of what Paris was to be upon a larger field during many centuries. I mean the struggle with Labienus. It was during the great revolt of B.C. 52, whose centre was the defence of Gergovia. It was the spring of the year. Caesar was marching south to the middle of Gaul, that mountain country of the Averni that had become the centre of a quasi-national resistance. He had not yet attempted the assault of the volcanic plateau where he was to come so near to disaster ; the revolt was still but partial, and he found himself between divided bodies of the enemy, the tribes whose active resistance had shown itself south on the Limagne, and northward in the valley of the Seine. He determined on a double blow ; he went himself against the first with the bulk of his army, and detached Labienus for the northern march against the Parisii.

Labienus went up with his two legions to Agedincum

68 PARIS

(which is the modem Sens), and formed his base at that town, where two other legions, the later levies from Italy, were awaiting him ; then, with the combined force of four legions, he marched north along the river valleys. His objective was Lutetia. There the revolted tribes had gathered their great horde under a chief called Camulogen, very old and wise. They waited for the Eomans under the woods, which were their refuge, and behind the marshes, that were then: best defence. It was behind one such marsh, most probably where the Essonne falls into the Seine, seventeen miles above Paris, that the Gauls drew up their line and expected the attack. Labienus had come some sixty to seventy mUes ; he had wisely followed the left bank to avoid the crossing of many streams, and found himself at last in sight of the enemy. But Camu- logen had chosen his position with great knowledge. The Essonne ran for miles through a marsh, which broadened to a mile or more in width where the little river fell into the Seine. AU day long the Eomans were at work attempting to make a causeway, with earth and faggots ; when the evening came they had gained nothing by their labour, and the impassable defence still cut them off from their line of advance.

In the operations that follow one has as good an example as the Gallic wars afford of the discipline that assured the final success of Eome. These operations are a succession of forced marches, of night-work, of sudden attacks made at dawn on insufficient sleep, of success depending upon the exact synchrony of distant manceuvres.

In the first place Labienus broke up his camp at mid- night ; fell back twelve miles up river ; surprised, and took Melodunum, an island village of the Seine, and captured

LUTETIA 69

fifty of those light barges on which the commerce of the river depended. He rebuilt the bridge that the inhabitants had destroyed, crossed to the right bank, and began after all these fatigues a forced march along the eastern side of the river, accompanied by his boats. So rapid was all this movement of more than fifty miles, that he camped north of the island of Lutetia just as Camulogen, with his great swarm of men, had completed a short retreat of seventeen miles, and reached the southern bank. The Eomans lay somewhere near the present site of the Louvre ; the Gauls where Cluny and the University are now.

The two armies were watching each other thus from either shore — between them the ruins of the village which the Gauls had burnt, and the broken bridges — when the news that was so nearly an end to the Eoman victories, reached them. Caesar had been defeated at Gergovia (long after, in a little mountain temple of Auvergne, they showed a sword taken from him in the battle) ; the j3Edui had risen ; the tribal revolt had become successful and general. Labienus had upon his rear, just beyond the hills of Enghien, the Bellovaci ; they had but to move to envelop his position. There lay between liim and his base more than seventy miles of hostile country, and the stream of a great river. The enemy had received the encouragement of rumours which were based on a definite success, and which had gathered as they passed northward the effect of a decisive victory. In this pass the lieutenant of Csesar " took advice from his own daring." He waited for dark- ness. At ten in the evening he carried out the following plan. The boats he sent down stream in the care of the knights, and told them to wait for him at a point four miles below — that is, nearly where the fortifications reach

70 PARIS

the river to-day, and the great viaduct crosses with its three rows of arches. He left half a legion — the recruits — m care of the camp, and another half legion he sent up stream with a few boats, bidding them show lights, and make a reasonable noise as they moved, so as to deceive the enemy into the belief that the army was retreating by river on to Melun. Then he himself, with the remaining three legions, the biilk of his army, marched silently for- ward and westward along the bank of the river. A storm aided him. In its confusion he surprised a few scattered outposts, and by midnight he had joined his boats ; before dawn he had his forces transferred to the left bank, and Camulogen, confused by all this ruse, found them just as day broke drawn up in the plain of Issy.

The battle closed between that position and the slope of Vaugirard, on what is now the site of Grenelle, just west of the Champ de Mars. On the right, under the hill, the Seventh legion broke the line of the Gauls ; on the left, the Twelfth, after a first success, were pushed back by the main body of the enemy, who were massed here round the person of Camulogen. Two movements decided the victory for Labienus. First, the Seventh legion was free in time to come up in the rear of the main Gaulish body, and to envelop it; secondly, that portion of Camulogen's force which had been put on a false scent by the ruse of the night, came up to reinforce him, but came up too late. The right wing of the enemy, entirely surrounded by the two legions, was cut to pieces, and there fell with them the old chief himself. The reinforce- ment coming up on the hill of Vaugirard at the close of the action was driven before the general advance that followed the victory. Such of the Parisii and their allies

LUTETIA 71

as could escape fled into the woods above the river ; and Labienus, as he began his march to join hands with Csesar, passed through the whole length of the position of those who, for a few days, had menaced to cut him off and destroy him.

This was the first of the great battles with which the history of Paris is associated. It was the first example in history of how the river valleys, converging upon the plain of Paris, and there finding a barrier of hills, turn all that hollow into the final battlefield of an invasion. It decided more than any other one action the issue of the great doubt of B.C. 52, and it is the introduction of that stable and enduring civilization which followed the Con- quest.

With the final settlement the legions returned; the great roads were planned and paved, the village rose up again as a town in stone upon the embers of the huts, the bridges were rebuilt. Lutetia took a place — one of the smaller tributary towns — in the great list of the new civilization ; and under the pressure of that iron order the city slips out of history for more than two centuries, and merges into the Eoman peace.

So far as the direct record of history goes, there is a blank between the last mention which Csesar makes of Paris (and that is when he computes the Parisian levy at 8000 men in the attempted relief of the siege of Alesia) and the episode of Julian's election four hundred years later.

In all this great space of time we have but half a dozen references to thecity ; and these, with the exception of the dates on a few edicts, are only geographical. Thus Strabo

72 PARIS

(who was a child when Caesar returned from the war) speaks of " Luchotetia," and Ptolemaeus, two hundred years later, does the same ; but there is no definite event to set down in aU that long period save, perhaps, the half-known coming of the first Christian preachers.

Our exact knowledge even of this depends upon the chronicle of Gregory of Tours, and that bishop wrote rather more than three hundred years after the death of the first martyr ; but he so clearly follows an unshaken tradition in the matter, that one can rely on the approxi- mate accuracy of the date which he gives — the middle of the third century — for the arrival of Dionysius the bishop, and Eleutherius and Eusticus with him, the deacon and the priest. We know that this date, 250 a.d., was not surprisingly late, for even in Lyons, which was like a little Eome, and closely in touch both with the capital and with the east, the great martyrdom of the first Christians was only in 170 a.d. We know also that the evangelisation of the Parisii cannot have been undertaken much later, because the Bishop of Paris begins to appear ia the ecclesiastical documents of the first haK and middle of the next century (for instance, Victorinus signs at Cologne in 346). Taking, then, this story of Gregory's to be sound history, it is the one and only relief to four hundred years of silence.

It would be an error, nevertheless, to pass over that period without description ; the civilization of the time — especially of its first three centuries — was complete and full, and it has of necessity left behind it a considerable group of ruins. From these a number of accurate inferences can be drawn, and if we also use the analogy of other cities similarly situated, consider their guilds.

LUTETIA 73

their system of municipal government, the change to the tribal name, the rise of the defensor civitatis, and so forth, we can reconstruct the life and the appearance of Paris without a fear of any considerable inaccuracy. As all the material side of this reconstruction depends upon architectural remains, it will be my business in what follows to describe, and to estimate the value of, the ruins that still stand in the streets of the town, or that have been discovered beneath its soil ; to show how they help us to a knowledge of the old limits ; and to use them as a foundation for a description of the Eoman city. These, then, I take in their order, so far as the dates can be told.

The earliest and also the most perfect of the fragments that remain to us is the altar that the guild of the Nautse built to Jupiter in the time of Tiberius, when Our Lord was teaching in Galilee. This little broken monument is a very wonderful thing. You may see its six battered stones to-day in the great, cold hall of the Eoman bath, which you get to from the Cluny; and these carvings ought to be the first thing for a traveller to wonder at in the modern city.

For, in the first place, they are the oldest existing witness of the civilization of Paris. Here you have a first example of that French art of sculpture which continues without a break to our own day; and here also you see the local gods, the divinities of the river and the seasons, who were later to take on Christianity and preside at the shrines of the city. Thus there is Keraunos, the horned god whom men prayed to for their cattle ; and Esus, the god of the Gaulish summer — he is reaping with a sickle in his hand. This old altar was found under the choir of Notre Dame in 1711 (luckily just in time for Felibien

74 PARIS

to add a full account of it in his great book), and was deep in a mixture of soil and building-rubbish close to the remaius of a buried wall ; but the stones had fallen apart, and, so far as one can make out from the rough account of the workmen, they may have formed part of the foundations. Therefore a theory has arisen that the altar was standing when ChUdebert, five hundred years later, built that first Church of Our Lady, of which I shall write in the next chapter ; that, of course, was the time of his great edict against the remains of paganism in his kingdom, and they think that the altar was thrown down and used in the foundations of his church. At any rate, we learn not only conjectural things from these stories, but a good many certain things as well; we have the inscription which runs thus : " To Jove the great and the good, we, the Guild of Boatmen, foimded this altar when Tiberius was Csesar " ; and as we may assert that it was the most important shrine of the city, we can infer a great deal from such evidence.

As, for instance, that already the local association was assuming (in all probability) the municipal functions which later it certainly exercised: for in these water- towns of Gaul the guild of water-traders, the "Nautse" became at last the principal organ of city government, and, we may be certain, handed down their organization to the communal revival of the Middle Ages.

Then we can be certain also that the Eoman language and the Eoman gods were mixed and settled with the soil of northern Gaul in that short space of two genera- tions since the Conquest. And, finally, from its position this altar is a proof of the principal example of continuity which the city possesses.

LUTETIA 75

This character of continuity is one that has been insisted upon before in this book, and that wUl be repeated many times; it is the great historical mark of Paris, and yet it is the feature in the modern town which the traveller least understands or hears about. You have here, within a few feet of the high altar of Notre Dame, a little sacred circle, on which the worship of the city has been held from the time when men first made a ritual: the altar of the Nautse, of the first Christian Basilica, of Childebert's church, of the present Cathedral, all stood here. It is the eastern end of the island, and it is this that explains the position, for it was at such points and promontories facing new-comers that the civic religion centred : this altar on the cape of the old island (the modern quays run somewhat farther into the river) met the commerce of the Seine, as the altars of the Cities and of Eome met the commerce of the Ehone at Lyons, or as the Temple of Mercury met the commerce of the Marne where it fell into the main stream. This altar, then, of the Nautse is the first and most reverend thing among the relics that remain of Lutetia.

Next, both in the matter of their probable date and of the time they were discovered, are the group of ruins and bronzes that were dug up in the centre of the island. It was during the reign of Louis Philippe, when the alterations in the Parvis of the Cathedral (that is, in the space in front of it) were being made, and when the court-yard of the Law Courts, a little to the west, were being relaid, that these walls were found.

They were the plans of certain houses and rooms, and their importance in the history of the city is as follows. The first (those in the Parvis) give us the alignment of at

76 PARIS

least two important streets ; they increase the probability that the main street of Lutetia ran right across from the Petit Pont to the Pont Notre Dame, and that these two bridges give the line of the old road; they prove the existence in the Koman time of a street running east and west, the main artery of the little town, and negatively, by the absence of further ruins between them and the Palace, they seem to point to that space as the Forum of Lutetia ; the public meettag place which should have stood just there, reached by the northern and southern bridges and full in front of the Palace and the Praetor's Court. These houses had no open space or court in the middle, as had the typical Koman house ; the narrow space of the island perhaps, more probably the climate, modified the southern type, and in spite of Julian's talk of stoves in the Palace, these private houses iu the city had certaioly the cellar- furnaces which we find in the Eoman villas of Britain.

As for the second discovery made at that time, it is without question a room or hall in the Palace which was first of all the governor's, and later in history the emperor's, when those wandering soldiers of the defence began to live in their distant provinces. It was foimd in what is now the courtyard of the Ste. Chapelle. It was well preserved and gave a clear plan ; on those fragments of wall that yet remained upright one could see the dead black paint, and the delicate festooned ornament of dull green that relieved it^ on its floor the decorations of the roof had fallen, and in the richness of their carving showed a little what the Palace had been. Here also, or rather just outside, and jutting upon the forum, was (we may presume) that little temple to Mercury which was followed by the small mediaeval Church of St. Michael.

LUTETIA yy

Both the houses of the Parvis Notre Dame and the hall of the old Eoman palace were covered in again just as they stood ; their bas-reliefs and the broken details went off to the Cluny, and the walls themselves were marked in the paving that was put above them. For this is a very favourite way in Paris of dealing with ruins which they do not wish to destroy, but which they cannot leave standing in the modern streets : they bury them, and mark the place with white stones on the pavement. This they have done with the foundations of the Bastille and the founda- tions of the old Louvre, but they have not done it with the magnificent ruins of the Eoman Amphitheatre, of which I shall speak in a moment.

The wall of Lutetia ran all round the island ; some parts of it have been discovered, and the corner of one of its towers. There is not much to be said of it ; less than twenty-five feet in height, very thick, and flanked with perhaps some thirty towers, square, and of moderate height, we must presume it to have been built of that same white local stone that has given so strong a character to the appearance of the ancient and of the modem city. It has been argued that the wall was necessarily of very late date, because the ruins of the Amphitheatre have been found here and there embedded in it : the argument is imsound. The period that used the old buildings as a quarry was not the period that built entire city walls, it only repaired them. One might as well reason that no walls surrounded Chester till the time when they pulled up the tombs of the legionaries to strengthen the fortifications of the city. Perhaps the most probable guess would make the close of the third century the time when the wall was raised.

With the details just described, and with our knowledge

78 PARIS

of what succeeded the Eoman period, we can get a very fair idea of the plan of the town in the first three centuries of its civilization. The island was a little smaller than it is to-day ; for, first, what is now the Place Dauphine and the middle of the Pont Neuf was then two little islands ; secondly, what is now the Quai des Orfevres was then a detached islet separated from Lutetia by a narrow ditch, and, thirdly, the broad quay round the south and at the back of the cathedral, with the Morgue, was then all water, for it has been artificially built out into the stream, and the island used to end very much where the little Gothic fountain stands to-day in the gardens behind the apse.

To get a clear conception of the Eoman town we must imagine the island divided into three sections, an eastern, a middle, and a western : the eastern going from the point of the island to the line of the bridges (the present Petit Pont and Pont Notre Dame), the middle going from these to the line of the Boulevard du Palais, just in front of the Law Courts ; the western stretching from these to the extremity of the island and the two islets where the Place Dauphine is now. These three divisions are stiU clearly marked in the modem arrangement of the island, and seem to belong to it of necessity throughout its history. Now, the first of these would contain, of course, the principal temple and the altar of the water-guild ; a small space would be clear in front of the temple, but for the rest the quarter would be full of houses, and a little port or dock (the only landing-place on the island) stood with its steps and rings just where, beyond the abutment of the Pont D'Arcole, steps lead down to the water to-day. (It was called later the Port St. Landry, having slipped under

LUTETIA 79

the protection of that bishop from the tutelage of some unknown Gaulish god.) All this would correspond roughly to the Cathedral and the Parvis and the Hotel Dieu.

In the central section (which corresponds to the modern Barracks of the Guards and the Flower Market) there was a belt of houses along the north shore of the island, and a belt of houses along the south bank, while between them was the Forum and the Temple of Mercury ; the Forum taking much the position that the Eue de Lutece does now.

Finally, facing the Forum, and stretching in a long colonnade right across the island, came the palace and the offices of the Municipal Government. They ran along the modern line of the Law Courts and of the Ste. ChapeUe. Covering as this great buHdiag did the whole width of the town, from one wall to another, the rest of the third or western section was cut off, and most probably laid out in the gardens of the palace. We know that it was all gardens in the centuries immediately suc- ceeding, and then, as during the Eoman time, there could have been no access to them from the town that stood on the eastern shores of the island, save through the archways of the palace itself.

Eound all this went the wall, regularly following the shore, and leaving room for a path and a steep bank outside it against the water. Only in two places does its regular outline seem to have been broken. The first was at the spot where now stands the southern transept of Notre Dame. Here, for some unknown reason, a bastion was thrust out southward from the main line of the wall.

The second was in the midst of the northern wall, where

8o PARIS

stood the prison which we learn of from the chronicles of the iirst Prankish kings, and which was then called " The Prison of Glaucinus," while beyond this to the east there stood at a very late date (probably after Maximus won his victory in the neighbourhood, at the close of the fourth century) a triumphal arch. This arch may have spanned the entrance to the city by the northern bridge, or may have been a little to one side of the main road ; its fragments were found near those steps which I have spoken of above as marking the site of the old landing-place.

If to these details one adds the strong towers at the head of either bridge one has, so far as it can be recon- structed, the plan of the city proper — of the island ; but besides the main town on the island, Eoman Paris possessed important suburbs whose total area must have been almost equal to the central portion within the walls ; and these suburbs we can trace with some accuracy, although we have, with the exception of the great palace on the south, very little left of the actual walls of their houses. If my readers will look at the sketch map which accompanies this description, they will see these suburbs marked, as the houses in the island are marked, by a shading of sloping liues. There are two, the northern and the southern.

The limits of the northern suburb I have given as accu- rately as one can with the small data at one's disposal. We know that there were houses at the junction of the great north road and the road to Augustomagus; and the discovery of a very great number of medals, coins, and what not, in a regular line beyond what is now the Hotel de VUle, as well as the presence of a number of relics of whatever was metallic about the houses, permits us to give with

LUTETIA 8i

some certitude the boundaries of this group of houses. Where the Place de Greve ^ is now in front of the Hotel de Ville there was certainly a landing-place for boats, and therefore I have left this spot bare in the map. Of farther Eoman remains on the north bank the most important is the reservoir which was discovered in the northern part of the gardens of the Palais Eoyal. It is a striking example of the care which the Eomans always showed to provide a plentiful supply of water for their towns, that this little provincial city should have had two principal aqueducts. The one, as we shall see, furnished the palace on the south bank, and probably the city on the island. The other, coming from the heights which are those of the Trocadero and the Arc de Triomphe, drew its water from a spring in what is now Passy, and came in a straight line across the Place de la Concorde to this reservoir of which I have spoken.

With the exception of the works for this supply of water, and of a villa here and there upon the two great northern roads, the north bank does not show any sign of Eoman work beyond the suburb. It was probably in the main a partly drained marsh and a chalky common, flanked at the western extremity of the plain by the fringes of a great forest. Montmartre, however, still shows, and till recently showed to a greater extent, evidences of the Eoman occupation, though they have not been so care- fully examined or described as have the more important Eoman remains of the island and its neighbourhood. When a traveller goes to-day to see the great basilica which has been built upon Montmartre, he notices close to it a little ruined church, which was in the Middle Ages

' They call it now the Place de I'Hotel de Ville.

G

82 PARIS

the parish church of what was then a small suburban village. This church (which was recently condemned to be destroyed, and which the efforts of French historians have luckily preserved) took iato its structure a consider- able amount of old Roman material, and especially some of its pillars are almost certainly taken from the two pagan temples of Mars and of Mercury, which stood at the east and at the west ends of the small plateau that crowns the summit of the hill. In the last century one could also see in the gardens of the Abbey of Montmartre a great wall just at the top of the hill where it overlooks the Plain of St. Denis, and this wall was all that remained of a villa, which some rich man had wisely built on this heirght, so that he might feel enthroned above the wide expanse below. His house was so full of statues, and had such fine great cellars for heating it in winter, that a pedant took it some century and a half ago for a manu- factory of pottery, not understanding that such places rarely stand on the summits of hills, far from the clay they need, nor that they would surely have an excess of ugly rather than of beautiful things. It was in this place that was found the bronze head which has so broad a forehead and such quiet brows, and which arrests you as you pass it in the Cluny.

When we come to the southern side of the river, we are struck by this, that while it was by much the more important of the two suburbs, and while it undoubtedly contains more that is Eoman than any other part of Paris, yet it is impossible to fix with any accuracy the position of its private houses. I have attempted to guess at the probable site of this suburban group, but I must repeat that in this case the greater part of the lines are conjectural

LUTETIA 83

only. We know that there was a port where I have marked it, just opposite the first of the two uninhabited islands at the head of the present Pont de la Tournelle ; and round this port there must presumably have been a certain number of houses. We know exactly the direction of the great road leading south from the bridge ; it lay to a yard on the site of the present Eue St. Jacques, and we know that the Palace gardens ran along its western side from the river. It seems probable that along the other side there stood a row of private houses. What is less certain is the plan of the city along the two lanes, one of which leads in the map from the Palace to the port, and the other of which branches out from this, and goes on to the Amphitheatre. The principal quarries from which the city was built lay upon the southern side of the first lane, very much where the market is now, off the Boulevard St. Germain and opposite the statue of the un- lucky faddist, Etienne Dolet. The sharp break in the hill, the wall which stands just behind the market sheds, still marks the line of the excavations. Since the same street that passed these quarries led to the port and also to the circus, we may presume, without too much fantasy, that a line of houses would follow so important a thoroughfare. It is possible, and even likely, that a few buildings marked the lane leading to the Amphitheatre ; but as no remains have been discovered on this part of the soil, I have left out any mention of houses there in my map.

When we turn from what is conjectured about the private houses to what is known concerning the public monuments, the suburb presents a very different historical interest. We have here a group of ruins and a number of accurately ascertained sites which are remarkable for

84 PARIS

having survived into the life of the modern city. In the first place there is, of course, that great palace of which one small wing stOl remains in the venerable brickwork next to the Cluny Museum. This, which was the old bath of the Palace, has given its name to the whole ruin, and has caused it for very many centuries to be called " The Palace of the Thermae ; " but very few modem men who know this one hall appreciate the immense size of the original building. It stretched all over the site of the present Hotel de Cluny ; its main central part went over the whole width of the present Eue des Ecoles ; one of its wiags would have covered the present site of the Sorbonne, while another would have gone westward to a point half- way up the Boulevard St. Michel. As to who built this great monument we cannot be certain, but we can make nearly sure that the tradition which ascribes it to Julian is unhistorical. Julian was devoted to Lutetia, but he passed too short a time in that town, and was, during his occupa- tion of it, by far too pre-occupied with his successful campaign, and with the military revolution which he witnessed and enjoyed, to have designed and completed such a building. It is much more likely to have been the work of his father, though it is quite possible that he was hinaself the first emperor to live in it in its finished condition.

Just south of the Palace, on the top of the liill, there has been discovered a group of Koman remains, which are less known than the Thermae, but which are of the highest interest. In the first place, it has been made sure that the great cemetery of the city, the tombs of the principal men, lined the main road in the Eoman fashion, and stood here in a field which, roughly speaking, covered the space

LUTETIA 85

contained between the Eue St. Jacques and the church of St. Etienne du Mont. Their sites, that is, lie at this day beneath the Library of St. Genevieve, the Eue Soufflot, the Pantheon, and the Law School.

Opposite these, just beyond the southern road, were the barracks of the garrison, corresponding to the centre of the Eue Soufflot, and beyond this again was a great enclosed space, which corresponds to what is now the corner of the Luxembourg Gardens, at the top of the Boulevard St. Michel and the opening of the Eue Soufflot. In this enclosed space the fair and one market of Eoman Paris seem to have been held, especially the market for the garrison ; for on this site have been discovered a very great quantity of small domestic implements, of soldiers' lighter kit, of coins, and what not, upon which the conjecture is based.

The Palace had also a great garden, and, though it had long disappeared, its general position was indicated so late as the twelfth century by the general name given to the whole quarter, the " Clos de Laas," or Palace Close. It is usual to make the wall of this Palace garden (for all trace of it has disappeared) run from a spot close to the southern side of the Pont des St. Peres straight south for a matter of a quarter of a mile, and then turn at right angles to meet the Palace itself. My readers will see that I have varied from this more usual conjecture by bringing the wall in at a re-entrant angle, so that the site of St. Germain de Pres lies outside the gardens ; and my reason for doing this is as follows. From the moment when the Abbaye of St. Germain was founded it is perfectly clear, both in the original charter and in all that the chronicles have to tell us of it for hundreds of years, that it lay outside whatever

86 PARIS

boundaries the city or the southern suburb can have possessed.

Now, that it should have stood outside the later mediaeval walls proves nothing, for by the time that the wall of Philip Augustus was built the old Eoman Palace garden had long ago disappeared, leaving no relic but the name of the quarter. But we must remember that St. Germain de Pres was founded at a time that was still virtually Eoman, within a generation of the death of Clovis, when Paris was still full of the imperial tradition, when the Palace was still intact and employed as a royal residence, and that it was founded, as the monastic institu- tions of that time were always founded, on waste land exterior to the urban district. It therefore seems to me impossible that the estate should have been partly carved out of the Palace grounds, and equally impossible that the church itself should have been built within the walls of the garden.

One last monument, the Amphitheatre, remains to be mentioned. The history of it is very curious, and is one of which we hear, unfortunately, very little ; for the strong "clamped walls were quarried during the Dark Ages, and, long before history and letters revived with the Crusades, they had become a low oval ruin, filled up with rubbish and the mounds and dust heaps of a suburb. Tradition, indeed, kept their memory for many centuries, and even when men had forgotten the meaning of the term, the phrase " Champs des Araines " preserved the sound of their name ; but in the absence of any more substantial proof the historians of Paris grew to neglect the legend, and as the spirit of exact research developed in Europe the name became at first discredited and then forgotten. Felibien

LUTETIA 87

mentions it, indeed, but timidly, and it was left to our own time to show how, in this, as in so many other instances, positive tradition was a surer guide than the negative evidence of documents.

Eather more than a year before the Franco-Prussian war, when the Eue Monge was being pierced on the flank of the old University quarter, the workmen, in digging the foundations of the new houses, laid bare a full half Of the old walls and of the arena. They could easily have been preserved as a public monument ; the lower courses of the solid Eoman building had remained intact everywhere, and the arena, with its curious passages, was as curious as that of the Colisseum ; but the unfortunate necessities of Court finance, and the speculations of which Haussmann was the centre, caused the petition which the antiquarians sent up to be disregarded. The ruins were covered in again, the Eue Monge was completed, and various speculators were relieved of a momentary anxiety. That is why a noble ruin which should have been guarded in Lutetia as a principal memory of Eome, is now hidden by two cafes, a butcher's shop, half a dozen private houses, and a street.

In goiag south along the Eue Monge one comes to a place close after the crossing of the Eue du Cardinal Lemoine, where the thoroughfare takes a bend southward. The Amphitheatre stood precisely where this bend now is. It may have been built somewhat late during the Eoman occupation, but certainly not so late as modern speculation has imagined. The coins found in it are not earlier than the fourth century; but it is difficult to believe that a town of the importance of Lutetia in the third century would have been without a place for its public games. At any rate, its use continued well into the Dark Ages, and

88 PARIS

there is more than one mention of its being repaired and used, and of games being given in it by the early Frankish kings.

With these monuments of Eoman Paris known, and with these conjectures as to the site of its principal suburbs, we possess what little is known of the plan of the first city.

The political history of the Eoman town whose plan has been thus determined is easUy told, for, tUl the very close of the period, it lacks all detail and even all con- tinuity. There are in these many centuries but two or three incidents upon which even tradition can throw any light, and the few allusions to Lutetia which the general history of the empire contains were made by men whose centre and interest lay quite apart from the provincial town. The first historian who could by any possibility have seen the future importance of Paris was Gregory of Tours, and with his chronicle we are already in the decline of knowledge. I must, then, give in their order such historic facts as we have, and show what conclusions may be based on them; but it is inevitable that they should be presented as rare and disconnected things.

The first of these is the preaching of Saint Dionysius. The whole story of the conversion of northern Gaul is confused and uncertain. Lyons, and below it the Province, were of the Mediterranean : their Christianity came mainly through Eastern missionaries; and though the famous martyrdom of 177 at Lyons concerned the army, yet the presence of so strong a Church at that early time in the Ehone valley was a phenomenon essentially metropolitan and southern. Celtic Gaul had in it something of ithat quality which ran also through Ireland and the Hebrides :

LUTETIA 89

thoroughly incorporated though it was after this with the Empire, that centre and north to which Paris belonged, had stood out for the old Druidism as late as the revolt of CivUis. The mystic spirit which the hardness of Eome had thrust back into America, returned with the decline of civilization, and not till a space was left for legend to grow, could the new religion come in and mix with the mist of the popular fancy. Then, not so late nor so fan- tastic as the Irish movement, yet late and tending to fantasy, the faith ran into the empty places of affection, and there grew up the Church of Northern France, which in its origin was fertile, almost to rival the islands, in enchantment and suggestion, and which was after many centuries to produce the supreme expression of this spirit in the Gothic which was its peculiar creation.

It is not, therefore, wonderful that the date of Dionysius' mission should be placed so late as the middle of the third century, in the generation that saw the organized missions of Eome supplant the similar individual efforts of the East ; nor is it wonderful that his name should have become associated with so many marvels, and that his little company should be remembered as a mysterious twelve; but it must be remembered that these marvels are of a date later, not only than his martyrdom, but even than its historian. The most tenacious of all the legends concerning it, the story of the saint carrying his head in his hand as you see him on the church doors, and the typical folk-lore that speaks of his three springs of fresh water, we owe to an astonishing abbot of the seventh century, of whom I shall speak in the next chapter. The martyrdom, which most probably took place at a milestone on the northern road, has very properly been placed on

90 PARIS

top of Montmartre, for humanity has always made its altars on hill-tops ; the abbey was founded certainly near his grave, but the detailed account of its building under Dagobert makes the certitude of that site less strong. Indeed, we have no acts of St. Denis, and all we know for certain is that the southerner did come, and then, to Lutetia; that Eleutherius and Eusticus, the priest and deacon, came with him, and that in him originates the See of Paris.

Some few names, each uncertain, each connected with that spirit of Celtic Christianity, succeed his time. Their very names suggest miracle — Yon, the most typical, carries the mind back to Brittany; and, indeed, Brittany has claimed him. As to the first bishops, whose names are the whole history of Lutetia for nearly a hundred years, their list stands for a growing power, for the Church re- placing the Curials and mastering the government of the cities, yet even the names of these men, whose history could tell us so much of the transition, are not fixed ; the sixth only, Victorinus, is a certain figure ; we have seen his signature at Cologne in 346, and it accompanies those of thirty-three other bishops of Gaul, at Sardica in the next year. With his name is connected the only striking passage of true history in the five centuries of Eoman Paris, I mean the episode of Julian's visit to the town.

That reactionary, whose character will always singularly attract historians, and whose literary weakness has dignified him with the title of Apostate, made Lutetia his winter quarters during the two years of his successful campaigns. It was to Lutetia that he brought back the triumph of Strasburg, and he made it the first of the southern cities to feel the new security which his vigour had purchased.

LUTETIA 91

It was in Lutetia that he summoned the Council of Bishops, and we may, if we like, construct a picture of this young Caesar sitting, as the lay master still sat, at the council, hearing the debate and the affirmation of the Nicsean position, seeing that letter drafted in which the West threw down the gauntlet of its faith against the official rationalism of the capital and proved in its passionate rebuke to Arianism the growing weakness of central control and of the Palace : the soul of Gaul strengthening dogma : the race that was to shelter Athana- sius, and to produce Ambrose to forge the Church. As he sat there he was turning in his head the scheme of his philosophy, and he was dreaming of a past which alone he comprehended, and which his victories might yet have revived. He had served the provinces in their hardest trial: he had given peace after one hundred years of invasion and of servile war. He held the two vicariates that were still the most vital of the provinces, he thought that so much success could transform the energy whose revival he mtnessed, and that his soldiery could remodel a vanished state. He was the general under whom St. Martin had served, but he could only see the world with his own eyes.

Here also in Lutetia, in the Palace of the Thermae, the soldiers called him Augustus, running down from their barracks on the hill to thrust the Empire upon him. Here he kept for a few months his little quasi-pagan court, and from that circle produced the first book ever published in Paris — a shorter edition of Galen, by one Oribasius, a doctor. He left Lutetia before the close of the year 360, and never returned. He had made it his centre of action for nearly four years, whose pleasant memory of success

92 PARIS

and adventure remained with him vividly through the short rest of his life ; for he had there found " the little darling city" of which he writes, so tenderly in the Miso- pogon ; the provincial town where the old virtues remained, and where Casar could still play at being a stoic. He dwells upon its pure river, its simple wooden bridges, its wiae (and that wine of Asnieres — which no one possesses now — was still famous in the Middle Ages), its contented people. He tells the story of his misadventure, how, in the cold of the winter he tried to work as he had in the south, and failed ; of the great blocks of ice, " like marble," that hustled down the Seine ; of the fig-trees, covered with straw to save them from the frost. All that he writes — the affectionate detail and the clear memory of trifles — is in the spirit of a man who preserves a delightful reminiscence. When he went south from this refuge it was to enter ceaseless battle and discussion, to take the definite and fatal step that has spoilt and misread his name, and to die in battle on the sands of that East whose spirit and in- fluence he had so dreaded. All the world knows the story of his lance thrown into the air when he was wounded, and of his cry to the Galilsean who had conquered.

Julian, who had meant to make Lutetia famous for its simplicity, succeeded rather in making it the fashion. His action had turned the provincial town into a capital ; both Valentinian and Gratian followed him in the Palace of the south bank. It was here that the court first heard of Carieto's defeat by the barbarians and of the victory that immediately succeeded it, and here was received from Asia the head of Procopius. It was here that there began and ended that short and fruitless reign, whose brilliance Theodosius avenged but could not recreate ; for it was upon

LUTETIA 93

the court of Paris that Maximus inarched in his strange adventure from Britain, to defeat it and to raise his triumphal arch in the city.

Then — or little later — at the close, that is, of the fourth century, Marcellus was Bishop of Paris. His life written by a contemporary might have given us with exactitude and power the transition of the time, and we might have learned, in what was still a literature, the language and the decline and change of northern Gaul. But, unfortunately, we possess no record of him save an obscure and ill-proportioned life written by some hagio- grapher in the fuU twilight of the seventh century. A mass of miracles, a paucity of historical detail, cover what might have been a record of the change from municipal government by the curia to the private power of one of&cial, from the rule of the bureaucracy in the palace to that of the bishop, from the old name of " Lutetia " to the new " Civitas Parisiorium."

Such a record would have made us see plainly much that we now seize so imperfectly : the gradual despair of the civil power; the new dream of the Church, which meant to bmld a city of God on the shifting sands of the invasions ; the light in which the provinces saw the final invasion, which perfected and concluded a century of uncertain defence. In the lack of that contemporary record we have but two known things with regard to the bishop. First, that almost alone of the great Parisians he was a native of Paris. Secondly, that he was buried (as now began to be the custom with famous men), not where the tombs were along the high road, but out beyond the houses, in a shrine of his own in the lonely roadside chapel of St. Clement, which stood in the fields to the

94 PARIS

south-east. Upon that shrine the spirit of the time created an immediate worship. A monastery was founded, houses rose about it, and with the opening of the fifth century there had appeared in this fashion the first of that ring of suburbs which were to coalesce and form in time the great mediaeval town. Each rose round some religious house, many of them venerated a bishop of the city, nearly all of them a local saint ; and in every cha- racteristic this " Faubourg St. Marceau " was the prototype. You may find it to-day fast in the heart of the workman's quarter to thesouth-east; and if the name seems to arouse some memory, it is because the Eevolution and the Cordeliers made it a twin to the more famous Faubourg St. Antoine, and armed its people in the decisive struggle against the monarchy.

The next and the last division of the story of Eoman Paris centres round the inexplicable figure of Ste. Gene- vieve. In the ruin of public order it must be imagined that many cities found in some constant and commanding mind a substitute for their lost institutions ; but no city presents the historical example of that necessity and its consequence so clearly as Paris. There is this also to remark in the action of the patroness, that while clerical influence was everywhere replacing the older bureaucracy, it was yet an official and an orderly force, hierarchic and centralized; but the appearance of this peasant woman by chance, her attainment of a position which was prac- tically that of defensor dvifatis, is the beginning of something new in the politics of Europe. I mean the spontaneous, personal, and individual force, which is to run throughout the Dark and Middle Ages, and which is to lend to that long dream of history its inconsistencies

LUTETIA 95

and its riddles. For a thousand years and more that bond of character was to work side by side with a tenacious conservation of the old universal forms and machinery of government, and to make society a kind of vigorous garden of weeds, held in by crumbling walls, and marked by paths that no man dared to change or to renew:

Of St. Genevieve's life we know little, because what we have of it is written late, and confused with legend. Germanus of Auxerre found her in the little village under the hill of Valerian, as he went along the western road to preach in Brittany (for the Bretons had taken to believing Pelagius when that Celtic individualist maintained that a man's sins were his own and none other's). She was seven years old, and the pleasure that he took in her innocence founded her legend. Later, in Paris, when the people rioted against her orders, her defender said, " Leave Genevieve without hurt, for I have heard Germanus say that God meant her to do great things." She was in the city continuously from, perhaps, her twentieth, to her death in her eighty-fourth year. She controlled it always ; she even governed it in her last years. She calmed the panic during Attila's invasion. She defended the walls against Childeric, and when she built over the neglected tomb of St. Denis its first shrine, she ordered the civic work with the authority of a regular executive. That, apart from legend, is all we know, but the incomplete and fantastic record permits us to see the outline of an extra- ordinary figure.

There must have been, even when Attila was riding with his half-million westward from Metz, the relic of a curial government; taxes of some kind must have been raised and defences repaired, yet the popular memory

96 PARIS

perceives nothing of such action. We hear only, in a later and distorted legend of Genevieve, with her visions of the terrible horseman, and with her prophecy that the city would be spared ; a girl of twenty-five had become, by some vagary of the popular instinct, the oracle of the city. As she grew into middle age she seemed to pass from this to actual government. She was a woman of fifty when Childeric was marching south. In the many years during which all communication was cut off between Paris and the southern civilization, she alone appears to have governed and succoured the people. When the Frankish king laid siege to it, she organized and com- manded the expedition that brought corn down by river from the champagne country, from Arcis and Troyes. If Childeric entered, it was to treat with her as with an imperial officer; and when his son succeeded to a more stable and determined power, the ordering of his new capital stUl lay with this woman, who watched in extreme old age the complete conquest of the Frank, and who seemed concerned only with the conversion of the bar- barians after Tolbiac.

Clovis, triumphant from his victory over the AUemans or from the defeat of Alaric, hardly shows as the prin- cipal figure in the capital ; it is still the old woman, whom eighty years of peculiar service had so endeared, that receives the news, and organizes, with the prevision of the enthusiasm in which she was steeped, the transition to the rule of the Germans. When she died the Eoman city had been handed on intact and unravaged to the new powers ; almost alone of the northern towns (unless we except Eheims, to which Eemigius had done some- thing of the same service), it maintained its old security

LUTETIA 97

and its old pre-eminence, and through her care in the moment of transition, Paris outlived the decline of centuries and inherited France,

I would close this chapter by an attempt to reproduce the city and the hills at the moment that the Frankish armies entered them. "When some chance horseman of Childeric's in the first siege, or an outpost of Clovis in his last bivouac north of the city, looked down from the flanks of Montmartre southward, what did he see ?

The plain, the roads, and the town, all still in their outer showing strong and orderly ; the governmental part of the great organism of the empire had lost its motive force, but it had retained its forms. The growing twilight of the mind was not yet reflected in the stones of the Gaulish capital, and the taxes, whose misdirection and enormity had helped so general a decay, were still col- lected and could still furnish that constant process of renewal which is the condition of vigour in architecture. The consecjuences of a political disaster which could per- mit the advent of the barbarian, had not yet reached the surface of provincial life; and the city which was to remain Eoman for so many centuries more, bore at this time almost an appearance of youth.

The road that stretched to the capital showed clean, well- paved and even, for the whole length of its dead straight level of three miles, to the point where it turned abruptly, and was lost in the houses of the northern suburb. The few viUas of the plain, with their ordered gardens and formal trees; the haK-drained marsh, with its fringe of market gardens ; the clearly defined edge of the eastern and western woods — all these spoke of a civilization not

H

98 PARIS

yet accustomed to the process of decay. Beyond the city the road ran in the same continuous Kne, straight up the Mons Leucotitius, past the round tombs and the deserted barracks of the summit, to follow its precise direction through the forest and on to Genabum, Everything in the landscape meant rule and long custom and the memory of law, and everything was ennobled and oppressed under the grave accuracy of Eome.

The city itself showed below the suburb stUl perfect and still southern before the eyes of this northerner, who only came out of his hungry forests because so much plenty remained to the Empire. It was white and orderly, show- ing sharply against its fields and the woods of the southern hills, and more clear in colour than it has been in any years of its later history ; for the little capital had not yet exhausted the shining stone of the first quarries, it still burnt clean charcoal fires in stoves and cellars, and the roofs sharpened all this brightness by the frame of red that the small Eoman tiles gave to the palaces and the temples.

The wall rose evenly along the water, with its Arch of Maximus delicate and clear ; the larger mass of the prison and the entry of the colonnade alone broke this northern side, while neilier in towers nor in the flat sky-line of the buildings was there any accident to disturb the im- pression of compact and united design. Upon the hill beyond, the sombre bulk of the great Palace, complicated in plan, full of brickwork and already old, relieved and served as a background to the white mass of the island : to its right ran the gardens along the river, beyond these the careful fields followed the stream in a narrowing band under the hills of Issy and Meudon ; to the left the little suburb went down the lane to the port where the barges

REFERENCES.

A. Administrative Palace.

B. Temi)le i>f Morcury.

C. Forum.

D. Principal Temple and Altar

of the Nautae. K. I'ort of the Nautae.

Between this last and tlie bridge a small black mark shows the site of the Prison.

In this Map the sites of Roman Paris are marked in black continuous lines, the prin- cipal monuments in black, and the conjectured positions of private houses are shaded in with sloping lines. The names are printed in Roman type.

The modern streets and monuments are marked in dotted lines, and their names are printed in Italics.

Aqueduct .•^•

HUMAN PAHIS.

[To face p. 98.

LUTETIA 99

lay, and beyond it in the country-side rose the tiers of the Amphitheatre on the slope of the southern hill. Perhaps there would have been seen also, faintly and a long way off, the high arches of the aqueduct where it crossed the ravine of the Bievre, still furnishing the baths of the Palace and the fountains of the forum on the island, while on the fringes of the forests up the hiU to the south and here and there on the riverside the villas stood, as on the northern plain, the last evidences of the old security.

This was the city which Genevieve had defended ; the furnished capital that Clovis entered for its wealth, the city that Puivis has drawn so admirably in his frescoes of the saint; it remained at this opening of the sixth century very much what Julian had loved; in spite of calamity it reposed safely upon the strong foimdations of its past society, and was ignorant of the end that was coming upon its world ; the age and weakness and decay of the next five hundred years, the ruined fisc, the broken walls, the failing splendours of a barbaric court, the belt of uncouth churches in the outer fields, the great rude gardens of the monasteries on all sides, the new accents of a speech unfamiliar and halting, the rich man turned soldier, and the slave become a peasant — all these fates stood ready for the city. But Lutetia did not know them. Genevieve and Clovis had thought her still the city of the later emperors, and she was for yet a few hesitating generations to play with increasing faultiness at the letters and the manner of her past, nor did even the Jewish merchants, fresh from the east, nor the last of the pagan nobles understand that the new armies were marching alone into the dark, and were taking with them, like an escort, the old majesty of the empire.

100 PARIS

CHAPTER IV

PARIS IN THE DAEK AGES

What kind of city did Paris become when the order and pomp of Eome had grown old, crumbled, and fallen into decay ?

To answer this question it is necessary to form a clear idea of the long dark time that followed the barbarian invasions. That vast period which we often vaguely and erroneously call the "Middle Ages," with which we connect the feudal state of society, and whose interest and tenor of thought appear to us so distinct from those of modern times, is by no means the one continuous era which our imagination too frequently pictures it.

Apart from the innumerable minor changes and develop- ments which make every part of it as diversified in its way as our own or the last century, the great epoch falls into two well-defined divisions, to the first of which the name " Dark Ages " may properly be given ; and to the second only of which can the term " Middle Ages " be applied.

We must remember that these two together deal with the space of a thousand years ; and the marvel is not so much that one revolution and total change in society should have occurred in such a prodigious lapse of time, but rather that only one such complete renewal should

PARIS IN THE DARK AGES loi

have taken place. The short four centuries since their close have given us, in the Eeformation and in the industrial and political revolutions of the last hundred years, at least three such movements and the immediate promise of more.

The two principal epochs of this thousand years are distinguished as follows. The first is that process of continual decline which, having its origin in the break- down of Eome — that is, in the Lower Empire of the fourth and fifth centuries — reaches its nadir or lowest point in the generation which saw the millennium.

These five centuries of the city can have a fascination about them which it is not always easy for a modern reader to catch. We are like men who stand on a high peak and look over many ridges of hills. Our success has hidden from us the bases of society, and we gaze over time from one complex civilization to another, forgetting that in the history of mankind these peaks are rare and narrow ex- ceptions; that beneath the mountains, beneath our own immediate standpoint, lies the great general level of which the bulk of the human story is made. That hidden level, that plain across which so many slow caravans have travelled, we call barbarism ; we study it as a curiosity, or fly from it as a danger, yet out of it we rose, and down to it the further slopes of our success will fall again ; for it is the repose of history.

Paris, between the century of Julian and the stirring of the eleventh century, went down into the valleys. Piece by piece the clear light, the artifice, the order and the monotony of the Empire crumbled ; tendril by tendril there rose up in the hollow of such ruined stones the natural growth of humanity; legend, miracle, the war

102 PARIS

song, the ordeal came in place of dissertation and codes. Less than a lifetime after the victory of Clovis two men disputed for a possession in Paris. The case was tried in the old Eoman Court, Each held his arms out in the form of a cross, and he that endured the position longest was given the verdict. That is but one example. In a hundred one might show how everything barbaric, absurd and native to man came in with the new rulers. The curve (if I may put it so) of natural growth replaced those hard lines of certain plan and arrangement that had distinguished the security and action of Eome, but we, in our modern methods, our certitudes, and our harsh lights, miss this dim and marvellous picture. That will be a study worth doing, the tracing of the slip back into natural things, when (if ever) we have grown humble enough to understand as well as to disbelieve the chronicler.

With the close of these centuries, with the crowning of Hugh Capet in 987, this period may be said to end ; and to the space of time lying between that date and our starting-point of 509, I propose to confine this chapter. For the year 1000, or, to speak more accurately, the generation immediately succeeding it, marks a turning- point. The ninth and tenth centuries may be said to have vied with one another for the evil primacy as to which was the most terrible : the heathen onslaught of the former and the brutal anarchy of the latter appear almost equally worthy to be called a furnace in which our civiliza- tion was tried. The second great epoch is connected, of course, with the first by a transitional period; but that period is comparatively short for the astounding work which it accomplishes. The long life of one man might

PARIS IN THE DARK AGES 103

have covered it, for a person born before the Norman Conquest of Sicily might easily have lived to see the discovery at Amalfi of the Eoman code.^

The whole of Europe awakes. The Normans show first how true a kingdom, with peace and order and unity, may be established. They accomplish this feat at the two extremities of Europe, the islands of Sicily and England. The Capetian House founds in France the origin of that strong, central government without which a state cannot live. The sentiment of nationality slowly emerges from the confusion of feudalism ; then come the forging blows of the Hildebrandine reform and of the Crusades, and the brilliant career of the Middle Ages has definitely begun.

The great kingships, the Eoman law, the universities, the vernacular literature, have appeared, and with them the Gothic architecture, whose survivals can prove to our generation, better than any historical evidence, how intense and how vivid was the new life of Christendom.

From that day, too, our own Europe has never lost its eagerness, its abundant vigour, its power of expansion, and it has held in its mental attitude a spirit of inquiry — the spirit which Eenan so admirably calls " la grande curiosite" — the basis of all our grandeur.

Now, in this chapter we have to trace the story of Paris during the downward half of the valley. What characteristics shall we discover in the five hundred years and more which this degradation covers ? Of the details in its history I shall treat later in the chapter; but before reaching these it is necessary to draw up some kind

' Oritics tell me that the code was not so found. It is a legend, and I prefer to believe it.

104 PARIS

of picture of the time, for without some slight sketch of the general movement of society in Gaul it would be impossible to understand the city. Let me, therefore, admit a digression on this subject.

In the first place, to use a phrase which may appear more than once in this history, Eome did not die ; it was transformed. On all sides, it is true, her civiliza- tion lost ground ; her art was rude, inaccurate, and, at the same time, less idealized ; her production of wealth less great; her architecture had become a matter of routine; her letters had grown crabbed. Only in one department of human energy had a change occurred, which a simple history such as this dares neither praise nor blame — the philosophy of the Empire had been touched with mysticism; the East had convinced the West; the shrine, the miracle, the unseen had replaced the clear and positive attitude, the speculative and cold intelligence, which had distinguished the philosophy of Eome in her time of greatest power. Mediaeval religion, with its legends, its marvels, its passionate abnegations, and its theories of the superhuman had appeared.

Was this advance of mysticism part of the universal decay, or was it, on the contrary, the one good counter- balance that ultimately saved the world from barbarism ? The answer can only be discovered in the attitude of the reader's own mind. It is a problem, the solution of which lies not in the region of historical proof, but in the department of mental habit, of conviction, . and of faith.

Gibbon would hint that it was the natural conse- quence of disaster and of decay working on a civilization that had already dabbled in the mysteries ; that with the

PARIS IN THE DARK AGES lo;

Saxons harrying the Channel, the Hunnish cavalry laying ■waste the central west, fear produced its invariable accom- paniment of superstition ; that Genevieve (if she existed ever) vp^as some leader of strong character, capable of organizing a prosaic resistance ; and that an ignorant and debased populace saw in her mission something of the incomprehensible, and, therefore, of the divine.

But Michelet, who is as great as Gibbon, and has (for his own people at least) a far truer sympathy, would undoubtedly yield to the mystic influence, and would picture to us, almost with devotion, the Church of the fifth and sixth centuries, because for him the people are its authors, and this conception of the people is for him the soul of history.

What were the causes of this beginning of decline? Perhaps the best general answer to so general a question is to say "old age;" but the proximate and immediate cause, or, if you will, the most obvious symptom of the break-down, was economic. It was in the form of a decline of wealth, especially of that method of producing wealth which the Eoman Empire had fostered with such marvellous success, that the pinch began to be felt. It was (roughly speaking) towards the close of the third century that the evil became marked. The system which Eome had spread over the whole of the west was one admirably suited to an inmiense expansion of wealth, and, therefore, of population. At the basis of it lay the con- ception of order. The Pax Eomana was a domestic as well as a political thing, and Eome made this duty of police the most sacred foundation of her power. She was savage in suppressing savagery; and when her task was accomplished, she had so strongly succeeded that, in the

Io6 PARIS

levels below the action of the civil wars, perfect order and peace had atrophied her powers.

In the second place, the idea of absolute property and of its concomitant, the sanctity of contract, was very prominent in her civilization. The right, "utere et abutere," to use or to destroy wantonly, was her exag- gerated way of asserting this dogma of individualism. It is in this source that we discover arguments for inviolable property in land, and from this source, again, that the extreme and harsh deductions of the common law (which equity came in to rectify on lines more consonant with Christian morals) proceed.

In the third place, excellent communications and practically free exchange completed the edifice.

Such rules of government are obviously calculated to increase productive power; and, indeed, those nations which to-day regard the accumulation of wealth as the end of civihzation have adopted a very similar code. Eome's success was the proof of the soundness of her premises. In places that are now deserts, wheat fields furnished the vast capital with food ; in the now half- barren uplands of Asia Minor she nourished a great population, and easily supported half a hundred cities. In Britain alone, and almost by agriculture alone, she may have found place for ten millions ; ^ in Gaul the forest villages became great and flourishing towns.

How did such a system begin to fall ? The conditions which Eome had established were favourable to — even provocative of — the growth of that disease of which our present civilization stands in such terror. A false system of distribution reacted upon the creation of wealth. A ' I follow Gibbon, and believe him to be right.

PARIS IN THE DARK AGES 107

few accumulated the means of production, and upon some only (but not the same) fell the burden of the State. A system of taxation well suited to a population among which wealth had not been ill-distributed, became onerous and almost intolerable as the conditions changed. What we should now call " the upper middle class " bore the chief share of the public burden. Will it be credited that when Gaul had passed through four hundred years of the Eoman system, many of this class voluntarily sank into a semi-servile status rather than continue to support the fisc ?

This, also, must be remembered, that the fixed charges of a State are like a trap, or like a wheel and ratchet : their action is such that they can advance, but they can hardly retire. It is easy to increase them in times of prosperity ; difficult, or impossible, to reduce them in periods of depression.

The system of production which Eome had introduced gave to the rich man great advantages. With his gangs of slaves, making use of the admirable roads and of a sea protected from piracy, competing with the poorer man under conditions where protection was unknown, he built up, not only in industry but in agriculture, a highly capitalistic system. The smaller men tended indeed to protect themselves more and more by a system of guilds, but those just above them fell more and more into de- pendence, sometimes actually into servitude ; and when the empire was at its height, great prosperity was gained at this price, namely, that but a few were actively con- cerned even with the economic welfare of the State, and that, as must be the case in any time of overstrained competition, the stability of the system depended upon

108 PARIS

the conservation of every iota of its gigantic energies. Were these to fail at any point, nothing could save it from decay.

For the production of wealth is not a mechanical process, governed by abstract and universal laws alone. It is men that produce wealth, and their power of pro- ducing much or of producing well lies all in the mind. It is from this truth that the effect of distribution upon prosperity proceeds ; let the mass of a nation become abject, or apathetic, or over anxious for the morrow; let the organizers of trade become careless through pride, or insolent from success, and no laws can save even the material side of a State. There is no aspect of society in which vices work out their own retribution more surely than in the sphere of economics.

The catastrophe (which was bound sooner or later to fall) was determined more rapidly than one might, in reading the glories of the Antonines, have anticipated. Within a century or a century and a half the great scheme of production was found " not to be paying." Taxation, which had been designed to lie fairly on the moderately rich, now crushed a superior but small and impoverished class, and beyond such an intolerable burden the Gurials had also to bear the entire responsibility of local government. Civil war, the apathy of the general citizen, a little less order, a certain shaking of security, and the decline began. The initiative which might have saved it could only come from the energy of a mass of small owners, and these had disappeared. In their place men in every stage of economic irresponsibility, the great bulk of them actually slaves, cultivated the vast estates or worked in the centralized manufactories ; and it even began to be more profitable to

PARIS IN THE DARK AGES 109

ask of these masses a constant fraction of the produce of their labour than to exploit them directly. Custom, in the decay of public order, was replacing competition, and the first note of mediaeval industry had sounded.

It was upon such a society that the barbarian invasions fell ; and that the reader may form a picture of the iifth- century citizen who endured them, I will ask him to imagine an owner of property living in the neighbourhood of Lutetia, and watching the course of events from the standpoint of that city whose outward aspect I described in my last chapter.

Such a man would have a house, let us say, on the southern road between the Mons Lucotitius and the hills ; before him to the north would stand the city, lying white and still perfect in the broad valley ; he would frequent it for its baths, for its news, and for its merchandise — possibly, also, for its public worship. He would probably be a Christian. That large body of Paganism which yet remained in Gaul was found rather among the people of the outlying districts, among the pedants in the cities, or here and there in the members of some old family still maintaining the tradition of their ancestors of a hundred years before. But his Christianity would be of the of&cial Eoman sort — his bishop of Lutetia virtually an ofScer of the State, his religion the State religion.

About his house a great estate would lie, and this was called a villa. The ancestor of our modern village, it was tenanted by a very different kind from the master — dependants, freedmen, slaves, living presumably as Latins do in a continuous line of houses along the road, the origin of the mediaeval village and cultivating the area of its parish. They would have their priest, their

no PARIS

regular time and place of meeting, their customs and traditions even as to the method of cultivation, in which their master would less and less interfere; and in their religion much of legend, of local tradition, of national folk-lore was included. They worshipped many saints whose very names their master had never heard, and they reverenced some who were indeed nothing but the old gods under new names ; they kept the feasts with haK-pagan ceremonies which all the world has since loved to observe ; and it is this lower community which forms our link with the prehistoric past. We owe it all.

The master of the villa spoke Latin, not more different from the conversational idiom of the Augustan era than is our English from that of the Elizabethans. His depen- dants spoke the more corrupt speech which they had learned from the Eoman soldiery, and in a hundred matters of ordinary life they used words of which the classics knew nothing. Their accent, in the growing difficulty of com- munications, was taking a strongly local tone, and, the terminations of the cases were already clipped in ordinary speech. StUl more effective, the accusative was being more commonly used in the place of the nominative, and no doubt, where their master would stiU talk of " Mons Luco- titius," they would make some such sound as " mont'm," or even " mont'," serve to describe it.

What would be the attitude of the master of the villa relative to the break-up of the empire going on around him ? In the first place, we must dismiss from our minds the conception of any patriotism. The empire was not a nation to be loved ; it was the whole of civilization — it was the world. That it could fall was inconceivable, and remained inconceivable to the Middle Ages.

PARIS IN THE DARK AGES in

The mind had long grown familiar to the idea of an infiltration of the outer barbarians. They had served, of course, in the armies; as pensions they had received frontier lands, and there was a long and continuous inter- course between the two sides of the border.

Even with invasion there was a considerable familiarity ; invasion was a part of the weakness of the government, but then the government was known to have weakened. The number of the clamourers, and their pressure, in- creased ; the shores of the narrow seas became untenable ; at last even Britain is abandoned ; still the Eoman citizen cannot conceive that his empire — the whole world — is coming to an end. Tribes of barbarians break through the lines on the north-east ; he hears that advantage has been taken of their courage — that they are allied to the Eoman forces. Some of them are given land. What of that ? It is but an exaggeration of an old custom. Anxiety, however, loss of security, the cutting off of